Another Vote for Roger Waters "In The Flesh" DVD. Simply incredible!!
On a similar note, a concert DVD that I was really looking forward to was Depeche Mode's "One Night in Paris" live DVD concert, but discovered that they sounded better in person at Fiddler's Green in Denver than the DVD concert was.
Wow I'm starting to feel "old" even though I'm only 30. I guess I have different tastes than most other folks on the board. My 2 favorite concert DVDs (sorry, so hard to decide) are both Criterion discs:
GIMME SHELTER
and
MONTEREY POP
For music video compilations I'd have to go with
SUPER FURRY ANIMALS
and
BEASTIE BOYS: CRITERION
Now that makes me feel young!
It's a good show, but the video borders on unwatchable. The footage comes from a streaming video feed they did of the show. You can tell the DVD was an afterthought.
Most disappointing concert DVD?
I saw Sir Paul McCartney at the Tacoma Dome last October and loved it.
However, the DVD was a fright. The camera concentrated more on the idiots* in the audience than the performers on stage!!!
* I'm not excluding myself from this group!