Sam R. Aucoin
Stunt Coordinator
- Joined
- Jul 5, 1999
- Messages
- 210
There is what some people may consider a "spoiler" about a particular scene, so please be aware as you read further . . .
Last week, I purchased this movie on DVD and we all (wife and kids) watched it one Saturday night. Pretty darned good movie.
But one scene particularly caught our attention: the one where Mel Gibson's character is telling his daughter that there are no monsters outside of her bedroom window when suddenly, he bolts upright from the bed as though he saw something standing atop the nearby barn. We reversed and reversed the scene and none of us could see what he supposedly saw.
We then went on to the deleted scenes section and saw that the scene in the movie was reshot. The alien in the deleted scene was clearly visible, and we all assumed that the point of reshooting the scene was to not make the alien so apparent.
For several years, my wife has complained that our TV is "too dark" - a comment many of you are probably familiar with after you calibrate your TV using one of the calibration discs (I used AVIA and Video Essentials). I told her (as I was told on these boards) that it was "supposed to be darker" and that after a while, you would be able to see "more detail" and "better resolution". Keep in mind that she is also in the category of people who does not understand why an explosion is louder in the same movie than a normal conversation (uh, because explosions are SUPPOSED to be loud - but I digress).
Well, yesterday, while sleeping late after pulling an almost all-nighter working, the rest of my family again watched SIGNS. This time, one of my kids (accidentally) had changed the picture mode of the TV (a Sony WEGA 36XBR250) to "standard" instead of "movie". This time, in the same scene as I described above, they clearly saw the alien - and made sure I knew by running into my room and shouting "it's there - it's there". I went into the room and saw for myself that the alien was, indeed, there. In fact, as I thumbed through the picture mode settings (going from standard, to sports, to vivid), the alien's presence became more and more apparent.
Now here is my question: Does this mean that my "movie" settings are too low (e.g., contrast, picture, brightness set too low), or does this scene "prove" that a properly calibrated set accurately "hid" what was supposed to be almost completely hidden (having seen the alien in the other settings, I can now faintly detect him in the movie setting)?
Thanks for any responses.
Regards,
Sam
Last week, I purchased this movie on DVD and we all (wife and kids) watched it one Saturday night. Pretty darned good movie.
But one scene particularly caught our attention: the one where Mel Gibson's character is telling his daughter that there are no monsters outside of her bedroom window when suddenly, he bolts upright from the bed as though he saw something standing atop the nearby barn. We reversed and reversed the scene and none of us could see what he supposedly saw.
We then went on to the deleted scenes section and saw that the scene in the movie was reshot. The alien in the deleted scene was clearly visible, and we all assumed that the point of reshooting the scene was to not make the alien so apparent.
For several years, my wife has complained that our TV is "too dark" - a comment many of you are probably familiar with after you calibrate your TV using one of the calibration discs (I used AVIA and Video Essentials). I told her (as I was told on these boards) that it was "supposed to be darker" and that after a while, you would be able to see "more detail" and "better resolution". Keep in mind that she is also in the category of people who does not understand why an explosion is louder in the same movie than a normal conversation (uh, because explosions are SUPPOSED to be loud - but I digress).
Well, yesterday, while sleeping late after pulling an almost all-nighter working, the rest of my family again watched SIGNS. This time, one of my kids (accidentally) had changed the picture mode of the TV (a Sony WEGA 36XBR250) to "standard" instead of "movie". This time, in the same scene as I described above, they clearly saw the alien - and made sure I knew by running into my room and shouting "it's there - it's there". I went into the room and saw for myself that the alien was, indeed, there. In fact, as I thumbed through the picture mode settings (going from standard, to sports, to vivid), the alien's presence became more and more apparent.
Now here is my question: Does this mean that my "movie" settings are too low (e.g., contrast, picture, brightness set too low), or does this scene "prove" that a properly calibrated set accurately "hid" what was supposed to be almost completely hidden (having seen the alien in the other settings, I can now faintly detect him in the movie setting)?
Thanks for any responses.
Regards,
Sam