Arthur Powell
Supporting Actor
- Joined
- Feb 15, 2018
- Messages
- 574
- Real Name
- Arthur
I wonder if George Lucas ever saw Chaplin's 1942 edit of The Gold Rush and thought, "Hey, that gives me a few ideas on how to treat my films."
Back in 2011 (has it been that long?) when the BD sets were released a total of over 6 million copies were sold. Nearly three and a half for the then complete set of Episodes 1-6, and just over 3 for the OT alone (episodes 4-6). But in 2011 physical media was in a sweet spot. In 2020 in would take a miracle to get those kinds of numbers again. Especially for the 6 million people that own the sets already, wondering why bother buying them a second time on disc.
No doubt there's an element of nostalgia in this, but I honestly think most of the changes are either pointless or for the worse. Greedo firing at Han Solo and missing from three feet away is plain idiotic, and it's followed by the Han/Jabba scene which regurgitates the exposition we've just seen.How about some heresy? I am perfectly satisfied with the re-cut special editions of the first 3 films. (Though, I am a completest, so I would buy the Blu rays of the originals if they ever were released).
I found the re-done special effects a revelation when the movies were re-released theatrically and really enjoyed the added scenes. When the DVD sets came out and included the originals as extras, I bought them as well, even though I already had the movies on DVD, but have watched them — or rather scanned through them, once. I find them inferior. They sit untouched on my shelf next to the Blu rays.
If you made a list, you would find hundreds of living artists that have re-tooled their art over and over, no mater what kind of art. Is it possible that the nostalgia factor is kicking in, and people just like the original version they saw as children, no matter how inferior? I remember being very disappointed with the obvious “puppet” Yoda, and really liking the CGI versions.
I respect your opinion and know many people who share it. I'm not one of them.How about some heresy? I am perfectly satisfied with the re-cut special editions of the first 3 films. (Though, I am a completest, so I would buy the Blu rays of the originals if they ever were released).
I found the re-done special effects a revelation when the movies were re-released theatrically and really enjoyed the added scenes. When the DVD sets came out and included the originals as extras, I bought them as well, even though I already had the movies on DVD, but have watched them — or rather scanned through them, once. I find them inferior. They sit untouched on my shelf next to the Blu rays.
If you made a list, you would find hundreds of living artists that have re-tooled their art over and over, no mater what kind of art. Is it possible that the nostalgia factor is kicking in, and people just like the original version they saw as children, no matter how inferior? I remember being very disappointed with the obvious “puppet” Yoda, and really liking the CGI versions.
What site?y, I didn’t think it was funny to think about this site coming out in 2011.
What site?
Edit function is your friend.Set! Typo!
Time flies. It seems like the set just came out for Star Wars but it’s been years!
It all depends on how you look at it. If George is going to force his altered versions on the public, with no intention of satisfying those of us who want the originals, and he succeeds in doing so due to stubbornness, then I guess in his mind he won. Unfortunately, for this issue, there are no winners- there’s just losers (us who want the original versions in the best video format possible). I can say I win because I refuse to buy the “special editions”- I won’t even watch them.Lucas won.
He was nothing if not a visionary, both in a business sense as well as a creative one. He seemed to understand that as Star Wars fandom grew beyond the initial generation who loved and treasured the unaltered versions that the demand for those unaltered versions would diminish. And so, here we are. How many who'd consider themselves Star Wars fans at this point even remember the unaltered versions? The "special editions" are now older than the originals were when the special editions were released (additional changes notwithstanding). There's an entire generation who grew up with and loved the prequels and now an entire generation is being introduced to Star Wars through the new films, enough so that those demanding the unaltered cuts be released have been reduced to a small, vocal minority. Add to that the fact that there's not much of a market for physical media at all any more (though Disney seems committed to 4K more so than a lot of other studios), and there simply aren't enough people left who both a) love physical media and b) are clamoring for the unaltered originals to make it worthwhile for Disney to restore and/or release them. I think more likely they'd include them, if they released them at all, as part of Disney+ in order to sign up new subscribers (especially those older fans who may not subscribe otherwise). But I honestly don't see it happening.
You may not like it (I don't), or you may not care (I don't really any more), but either way, it's time to admit that it's over.
Lucas won.