ClassicTVMan1981X
Screenwriter
I know, it really is a mess with Star Trek (TOS)... for example:Yeah, but so many shows have weird credit edits for no logical reason. Voyage to the Bottom of the Sea has two episodes in the 4th where the main title music was changed to the earlier version while retaining the graphics, and one where the end titles were altered. Land of the Giants uses the first season music over second season graphics in the openings of the UK box set.
Star Trek had all sorts of credit changes in the first season releases starting as far back as VHS.
While I agree that CBS made digital transfers of the camera negatives, it's entirely within the realm of possibility that they made changes to the opening of the pilot, because that's what these labels seem to love to do (I Dream of Jeannie and Bewitched, anyone?). We probably won't ever know for sure, and I hate to beat this discussion into the ground, but the fact that the edit is so clumsy leads me to think it was not as originally broadcast. And we know the first two episodes of the second season had slightly different segues from the preview clip into the opening titles than seen on the DVDs. The original Nu Ventures VHS tapes confirmed that.
When it comes to DVD releases of classic series, even the slightest, most unnecessary change is possible. Often even probable.
The first two episodes ("The Man Trap" and "Charlie X") bore a title card which had the title graphic with Gene Roddenberry's name below it. These two episodes not only had the electric violin version of the theme tune, but William Shatner's narration is a bit different than on "The Naked Time" and thereafter, with no pause between "These are the voyages of the Starship Enterprise" and "Its five-year mission." "The Naked Time" and "Mudd's Women" had the same electric violin version of the theme, but with the more familiar S1 opening credits without Gene Roddenberry's name in it, and also had both "Starring" and "Also Starring" placed above the respective billings of William Shatner and Leonard Nimoy.
~Ben