Brian Kidd
Senior HTF Member
- Joined
- Nov 14, 2000
- Messages
- 2,555
Back in the days of laserdisc, many supplements consisted of text supplements including images and the occasional video clip. A few dvds that were ports of earlier ld sets carried these over, i.e. T2, and THE SOUND OF MUSIC. I'm going to go out on a limb with what I'm sure is an unpopular opinion, but I must say that I really prefer them over the glossy and often uninformative featurettes included on most releases nowadays. My reasoning is that text supplements allowed for an almost infinite depth to the material. You could truly learn everything there was to know about a film from reading them (the good ones, at least) whereas video already limits the amount of material due to its very nature as a time-intensive medium. Certainly there are exceptions, such as the wonderful LOTR:EE sets, but such releases are few and far between. So many modern supplements serve as little more than EPK material and videogame commercials. A lot of them really talk down to the audience.
Now, I'm no fool. I realize that with most releases, the supplemental material must be created with the lowest common denominator in mind. However, if a film is being geared toward a specific niche, wouldn't it make sense to also cater to that more-discerning audience by including as much material as possible in the most cost-effective manner possible, i.e. text supplements? I honestly miss being treated as though I might have a brain and can read.
*flame-retardant suit ON*
Now, I'm no fool. I realize that with most releases, the supplemental material must be created with the lowest common denominator in mind. However, if a film is being geared toward a specific niche, wouldn't it make sense to also cater to that more-discerning audience by including as much material as possible in the most cost-effective manner possible, i.e. text supplements? I honestly miss being treated as though I might have a brain and can read.
*flame-retardant suit ON*