MarcoBiscotti
Senior HTF Member
- Joined
- Sep 2, 2003
- Messages
- 4,799
I've been debating whether to settle between a Sharp XVZ-12000 DLP or Digital projection I Vision HDX DLP projector and one of the issues has been the higher contrast ration of the sharp which displays a 5500:1 over DPI's standard 4000:1 contrast.
I mentioned this to an HT expert/delaer today who I've been working with and his response was... "Do you like staring into the sun?"
I obviously responded, "no." and he basically told me that that is essentially the equivalent and that most cinema theatres stick with approx. 4000:1 contrast ratio for a reason. He said that the higher the contrast, the more the color tends to shift and since more light is being reflected off the screen, it would be much too bright.
I was concerned because my HT is surrounded by two floor-to-ceiling windows on both a back and side wall opposite the screen, and while I have curtains and blinds and tend to generally make use of the room at night, my control of lighting is not premium. There is still some ambient light, but I don't think it's to a degree that it would interefere significantly with my HT viewing experience.
I'd like to know what your take is on the contrast issue?
I'm basically trying to determine whether I'm going to stick with the Sharp XVZ-12000 which is a significantly LARGER unit and has much more fan noise - which is NOT a good thing considering the projector would be directly over head above the seating area and the room space is fairly tight and compressed.... or the Digital Projection I Vision HDX which is much smaller, quieter, but offers less contrast w/ a 4000: 1 ratio.
-----------------------------------
BTW, Here are the specs for the DPI IVISION HD, in case you are not farmiliar with the projector...
http://www.projectorcentral.com/Digi...iVision_HD.htm
or
http://projectorcatalog.com/info/projectors_2972.html
AND
The Sharp XVZ-12000 obviously...
http://www.shopping.com/xPF-Sharp_Sh...12000_22033910
---------------------------------------------------
Please let me know what you thinka nd if you could please answer my question regarding contrast and what you think about what I was told, it would really be appreciated and help me out a lot!!
I mentioned this to an HT expert/delaer today who I've been working with and his response was... "Do you like staring into the sun?"
I obviously responded, "no." and he basically told me that that is essentially the equivalent and that most cinema theatres stick with approx. 4000:1 contrast ratio for a reason. He said that the higher the contrast, the more the color tends to shift and since more light is being reflected off the screen, it would be much too bright.
I was concerned because my HT is surrounded by two floor-to-ceiling windows on both a back and side wall opposite the screen, and while I have curtains and blinds and tend to generally make use of the room at night, my control of lighting is not premium. There is still some ambient light, but I don't think it's to a degree that it would interefere significantly with my HT viewing experience.
I'd like to know what your take is on the contrast issue?
I'm basically trying to determine whether I'm going to stick with the Sharp XVZ-12000 which is a significantly LARGER unit and has much more fan noise - which is NOT a good thing considering the projector would be directly over head above the seating area and the room space is fairly tight and compressed.... or the Digital Projection I Vision HDX which is much smaller, quieter, but offers less contrast w/ a 4000: 1 ratio.
-----------------------------------
BTW, Here are the specs for the DPI IVISION HD, in case you are not farmiliar with the projector...
http://www.projectorcentral.com/Digi...iVision_HD.htm
or
http://projectorcatalog.com/info/projectors_2972.html
AND
The Sharp XVZ-12000 obviously...
http://www.shopping.com/xPF-Sharp_Sh...12000_22033910
---------------------------------------------------
Please let me know what you thinka nd if you could please answer my question regarding contrast and what you think about what I was told, it would really be appreciated and help me out a lot!!