JerryMa
Stunt Coordinator
- Joined
- Aug 11, 2003
- Messages
- 93
Last night I went to J&R to check out the JBL Northridge E50s. A friend was in the market for new speakers and I recommended he check out the JBLs based on the low prices and what I've read in this forum, especially over the last week or two. He wound up buying a pair of E30s on the spot.
J&R also carries NHT speakers, and I've been curious about the SB3; while I'll do a more detailed audition Friday to make my final decision, I did spend some time listening to the JBLs and the NHTs. They were both run through a Denon 2803.
I heard the SB3 first. The speakers are on a shelf that's probably higher than they should be for optimal listening, but since they may be set up this way in my home, I was actually happy with the in-store set-up. The in-store CD featured a jazz track, which I listened to for both speakers. I was quite impressed with the SB3. The bass was amazing for the small size of the speaker. The SB3s were very clear. Imaging was good not great, but this could be because of the room, speaker placement, etc. I found the highs clear without being overly bright, although alto sax seemed to strain the speaker's capability a little bit. I didn't feel that the SB3s would be fatiguing.
I listened to the E50 next. The E50 was on a shelf that was about my ear level while I was standing. The overall sound was very lush, with great bass. The high end was very smooth without the slight brightness I picked up in the SB3; the aforementioned alto sax was very clean at the highest notes. Imaging was slightly better than the SB3, but the E50s didn't seem as clear and detailed.
Based on what I heard, I think I'd be very happy with either speaker. I did leave feeling that the E50s had a slight edge, but not by much. I'll get a better idea after I listen to some of my own CDs when I go back on Friday. The JBLs certainly have an edge in price and really are a great value. Stay tuned....
J&R also carries NHT speakers, and I've been curious about the SB3; while I'll do a more detailed audition Friday to make my final decision, I did spend some time listening to the JBLs and the NHTs. They were both run through a Denon 2803.
I heard the SB3 first. The speakers are on a shelf that's probably higher than they should be for optimal listening, but since they may be set up this way in my home, I was actually happy with the in-store set-up. The in-store CD featured a jazz track, which I listened to for both speakers. I was quite impressed with the SB3. The bass was amazing for the small size of the speaker. The SB3s were very clear. Imaging was good not great, but this could be because of the room, speaker placement, etc. I found the highs clear without being overly bright, although alto sax seemed to strain the speaker's capability a little bit. I didn't feel that the SB3s would be fatiguing.
I listened to the E50 next. The E50 was on a shelf that was about my ear level while I was standing. The overall sound was very lush, with great bass. The high end was very smooth without the slight brightness I picked up in the SB3; the aforementioned alto sax was very clean at the highest notes. Imaging was slightly better than the SB3, but the E50s didn't seem as clear and detailed.
Based on what I heard, I think I'd be very happy with either speaker. I did leave feeling that the E50s had a slight edge, but not by much. I'll get a better idea after I listen to some of my own CDs when I go back on Friday. The JBLs certainly have an edge in price and really are a great value. Stay tuned....