Nelson Au
Senior HTF Member
- Joined
- Mar 16, 1999
- Messages
- 19,131
I have the Masters of Cinema blu ray of The Flight of the Phoenix. I did a direct A-B comparison to the previous 20th Century Fox DVD. I queued up both films and played them and flipped back and forth between the two. in looking at both, the source appears to be the same used on the old DVD and the MoC blu ray. The only difference I saw in the image was the Blu ray is sharper. Color grading is the same.
So of course I can’t say what the correct color grading is supposed to be. But I’d be inclined to believe that Criterion is more accurate. The old source used to make the DVD may not have been corrected at the time? From that screen cap above, it looks like the old yellowed layer of varnish was cleaned off and we see the true colors.
So of course I can’t say what the correct color grading is supposed to be. But I’d be inclined to believe that Criterion is more accurate. The old source used to make the DVD may not have been corrected at the time? From that screen cap above, it looks like the old yellowed layer of varnish was cleaned off and we see the true colors.