David Williams
Senior HTF Member
- Joined
- Mar 6, 2001
- Messages
- 2,288
- Real Name
- David Williams
After quite a big build-up in the season finale, this episode was really quite disappointing.
Piper & Phoebe ripping into Paige for helping an innocent, works counter to what the audience wants. I think the storyline was some real merit, but only if the sisters find a way to fight evil while protecting their identities. Which brings us to the only exciting part of the episode, the two appearances of the Super Alias/Matrix-type Apprentice? Witch. College student by day, fighting evil by night is the ticket.
I see what TPTB are trying to do by redefining the Charmed universe, but it needs some finessing that I can only hope will appear in future episodes. No magic = No sale!
You know, after one too many Demons-in-the-House-trying-to kill-us moments, you'd think the sisters would find/write a protection spell for the Manor. If it's good enough for Magic School...
Piper & Phoebe ripping into Paige for helping an innocent, works counter to what the audience wants. I think the storyline was some real merit, but only if the sisters find a way to fight evil while protecting their identities. Which brings us to the only exciting part of the episode, the two appearances of the Super Alias/Matrix-type Apprentice? Witch. College student by day, fighting evil by night is the ticket.
I see what TPTB are trying to do by redefining the Charmed universe, but it needs some finessing that I can only hope will appear in future episodes. No magic = No sale!
You know, after one too many Demons-in-the-House-trying-to kill-us moments, you'd think the sisters would find/write a protection spell for the Manor. If it's good enough for Magic School...