Mark Kalzer
Second Unit
- Joined
- Mar 19, 2000
- Messages
- 443
At least according to this BBC poll.
I'd actually come closer to calling this poll the worst poll ever, rather than the movie. While I admit that Titanic has it's flaws, I still find love for it. There's a hell of a lot worse movies than Titanic could be.
There's also the placement of AI : Artificial Intelligence at second place which just makes me shake my head in disgust. I know that some people don't like science fiction, I just listened to someone claim that science fiction blows because...'I don't like it. It bores me.' I realize that the third act may have gone too far, (I don't agree with that assumption), but I just get the idea that this is another case of this being a sci-fi flick with no action or explosions, boring so many people.
What is wrong with this poll? It's obvious that it is based purely on people voting specifically for their most hated movie. There's nothing scientific about that at all. It's actually no surprise that Titanic was chosen. The highest grossing box office, all the Oscars it won, means that the people who disliked got really angry, and there's bound to be a lot of them considering how many people saw it. Apparantly, enough to give it the most votes. I'm not saying they're wrong in thinking that way, I'm just showing how that makes Titanicthe worst movie ever, according to this Jonathon Ross.
Also, there's the problem regarding this being based on viewers voting in. The average joe on the whole are not the best of judge as to what is the best or worst film. Obviously they can't have seen every movie ever made. Really, how could anything like Gigli come out on top in this? No one bothered to see it after the reviews came out, certainly not as many as saw Titanic.
The IMDB ratings are far more scientific in that while still coming from random public votes, they balance bad ratings with good ratings, which this poll gives no such opportunity for.
I guess this irks me because it reads like some snobby jounalist, or this host Jonathon Ross, just wanting to continually remind us that "TITANIC SUCKS.", and he uses such baseless methods to back it up with.
[/rant]
I'd actually come closer to calling this poll the worst poll ever, rather than the movie. While I admit that Titanic has it's flaws, I still find love for it. There's a hell of a lot worse movies than Titanic could be.
There's also the placement of AI : Artificial Intelligence at second place which just makes me shake my head in disgust. I know that some people don't like science fiction, I just listened to someone claim that science fiction blows because...'I don't like it. It bores me.' I realize that the third act may have gone too far, (I don't agree with that assumption), but I just get the idea that this is another case of this being a sci-fi flick with no action or explosions, boring so many people.
What is wrong with this poll? It's obvious that it is based purely on people voting specifically for their most hated movie. There's nothing scientific about that at all. It's actually no surprise that Titanic was chosen. The highest grossing box office, all the Oscars it won, means that the people who disliked got really angry, and there's bound to be a lot of them considering how many people saw it. Apparantly, enough to give it the most votes. I'm not saying they're wrong in thinking that way, I'm just showing how that makes Titanicthe worst movie ever, according to this Jonathon Ross.
Also, there's the problem regarding this being based on viewers voting in. The average joe on the whole are not the best of judge as to what is the best or worst film. Obviously they can't have seen every movie ever made. Really, how could anything like Gigli come out on top in this? No one bothered to see it after the reviews came out, certainly not as many as saw Titanic.
The IMDB ratings are far more scientific in that while still coming from random public votes, they balance bad ratings with good ratings, which this poll gives no such opportunity for.
I guess this irks me because it reads like some snobby jounalist, or this host Jonathon Ross, just wanting to continually remind us that "TITANIC SUCKS.", and he uses such baseless methods to back it up with.
[/rant]