What's new

A Few Words About A few words about...™ The Great Escape -- in Blu-ray (1 Viewer)

Robert Harris

Archivist
Reviewer
Senior HTF Member
Joined
Feb 8, 1999
Messages
13,584
Real Name
Robert Harris
XenForo Template

"I don't think it matters what his motives were. It was a brilliant bit of soldiering."The Great Escape has always been a sort of "event" film. Overflowing with the faces of some of the greatest British cinematic talent. Faces for which one may not be able to attach a name, but faces that you will see again and again through decades of British productions.Add to that a few recognizable faces from The Colonies -- Steve McQueen, James Garner, James Coburn -- and you're in for a treat.With top drawer production values as wrangled by Walter Mirisch, an amazingly intelligent screenplay, great direction from John Sturges, Daniel Fapp's cinematography, and that score by the incomparable Elmer Bernstein, and the end result is not only an extraordinary piece of entertainment, but one of the finest films about WWII.I've just spent some quality time with MGM's new Blu-ray. For the record, I have no inside information as to what was done. I can only relate what my eyes are telling me.There is no doubt that this is a digital presentation, but so are many other catalog titles as they're prepped for Blu-ray and DCPs. It's a safe bet that The Great Escape was photographed on Eastman 5250, the first color negative stock to have a decent lifespan, as if kept well, it doesn't have horrible fade characteristics. Some of the most important films ever created have been shot on 5250.Dupes, for both opticals as well as built-in printer functions are a problem, but they are what they are. I would love to have seen this film built for A / B roll printing, but apparently that wasn't the case printing to Eastman color direct positive in 1963.The Great Escape is 172 minutes long, and I was troubled by a single shot that I might have tried to massage just a bit.Other than that, understanding the age of the elements, wear and tear, and obvious digital work performed, I'm thrilled with MGM's presentation. "Grain" levels are acceptable, color looks correct, contrast and black levels, inclusive of those for dupes, are within a comfortable range for a 5250-based production.Audio, provided in DTS-HD MA 5.1 beautifully, and fully, reproduces the rich tones of the original.I'll make the point again. I have no idea what digital tools were used to create this new version of The Great Escape, but I'm seeing nothing untoward, nothing distressful, and nothing with an obvious overzealous digital bent.As an aside, I cannot see James Donald in anything without thinking of this quote which came just before the intermission of a film with similar story lines:"By the way, sir, I meant to tell you, there are trees in this forest very similar to elm. And the elm piles of London Bridge lasted six hundred years."This is a terrific presentation of a classic film that beautifully stands the test of time, as presented by MGM on a beautifully crafted Blu-ray disc.Note: I was contacted after this posting by Mr. Koster, who feels that another appropriate quote would be "Madness! Madness!" I concur, although his quote may tie in toward the use of that wonderful marketing term, "restoration."After digesting everything that I've seen, I come away with the overall thoughts, "pretty," and to use a golfing term, MGM-"handicap." But whatever it is that's on screen, enlarged in projection, works in the overall, and no doubt represents a fine achievement for the studio, and the best that we are apt to ever see.There are multiple ways of considering this Blu-ray. None are incorrect.Image - 4.5Audio - 5Highly Recommended.RAH

 

Rob_Ray

Senior HTF Member
Joined
Apr 12, 2004
Messages
2,072
Location
Southern California
Real Name
Rob Ray
Terrific news! At the price Amazon was charging, I bought without hesitation, and am glad that the results will be worth the price and more. It arrived last night and I hope to watch it this weekend. However, I must say I do miss the "special edition" packaging films such as this received on laserdisc (color gatefold jackets and then the full Criterion treatment) and even the earlier DVD. You'd never know from the bluray packaging that this was something that stands head and shoulders above most films. It looks like something that belongs in the clearance bins at WalMart.
 

Steve Tannehill

R.I.P - 4.28.2015
Senior HTF Member
Joined
Jul 6, 1997
Messages
5,547
Location
DFW
Real Name
Steve Tannehill
And for a street price of $9.99, a true no-brainer. Thanks for the review!
 

Richard V

Senior HTF Member
Joined
May 14, 2009
Messages
2,919
Real Name
Richard
Excellent news, my copy should arrive very soon, can't wait to watch it. One of my all time favorites.
 

Ronald Epstein

Founder
Owner
Senior HTF Member
Joined
Jul 3, 1997
Messages
57,436
Real Name
Ronald Epstein
Very happy to hear this news. I wrongfully overreacted to those
that read other reviews on other sites that spouted very negative
remarks concerning the transfer. I value Robert's opinion and
appreciate reading the many other positive remarks coming from
members just receiving their copy.

Speaking of which...

If you preordered your copy from Amazon at $14.99, I am certain
you are aware the price dropped to $9.99 on the day of release.

Amazon may have charged you $14.99, as they did me. I actually
had to send an email to their CONTACT address to notify them of
the price drop. As is always the case in these instances, Amazon
acknowledged they should have charged me the lower price and
I am being credited. Please be certain you were not overcharged.
 

Richard V

Senior HTF Member
Joined
May 14, 2009
Messages
2,919
Real Name
Richard
Ron, glad you mentioned this. I went to my account page, and they too charged me the 14.99 price, but when I scrolled down, I saw they had already caught their error and were in the process of giving me my overcharge credit. Classy company.
 

Robert Harris

Archivist
Reviewer
Senior HTF Member
Joined
Feb 8, 1999
Messages
13,584
Real Name
Robert Harris
Robert Crawford said:
RAH,

If cost wasn't a concern, could they have done more to improve the video presentation?
Robert,

I can't answer that without examining the elements, but my gut reaction is possibly, but not a great deal. This is a nice effort.

RAH
 

Billy Batson

Senior HTF Member
Joined
Feb 19, 2008
Messages
3,679
Location
London
Real Name
Alan
Well that's a turn up for the books after all the internet buzz. I did post a couple of months ago that I wanted this to look good, just good, not stunning. It didn't look stunning at the pictures, it looked...good, like all films did in those days. My fear was that it would get a revisionist grade, you know, in a bleak POW camp & a tragic ending, let's take half the colour out & make it nice & cool. It doesn't look like that's happend.
 

Ronald Epstein

Founder
Owner
Senior HTF Member
Joined
Jul 3, 1997
Messages
57,436
Real Name
Ronald Epstein
Classy company.
I rarely buy any Blu-ray/DVD product from anyone
except Amazon. They always back up what they sell
and in cases like these, they will always make certain
you get charged the lowest price from the day you
preorder to the day it ships.
Now back to discussing The Great Escape...
 

Robert Crawford

Crawdaddy
Moderator
Patron
Joined
Dec 9, 1998
Messages
51,100
Location
Michigan
Real Name
Robert
Robert Harris said:
Robert,

I can't answer that without examining the elements, but my gut reaction is possibly, but not a great deal. This is a nice effort.

RAH
Thank you for the quick reply.

Three different sites poo poo this release, but the HTF is the one that started to say hold up now. It's not that bad and is better than what some were saying about it.
 

Ray H

Senior HTF Member
Joined
Jun 13, 2002
Messages
3,558
Location
NJ
Real Name
Ray
When I saw all the negative reviews and compared the words to the screenshots, I could tell everyone was overreacting. I received my copy early and sampled some scenes over the weekend. It looked just fine to me. Good to know it has your approval, Robert!

I hope reason will be enough to quell the angry mobs on the other forums!
 

haineshisway

Senior HTF Member
Joined
Oct 26, 2011
Messages
4,888
Location
Los Angeles
Real Name
Bruce
Glad to see this - as you know I wrote similar things yesterday in the other thread and a lengthy piece about it in my daily blog today.
 

jsteed

Grip
Joined
Feb 5, 2013
Messages
23
Real Name
John Myers
Just finished watching the movie and am very impressed with the Bluray as well. I thought it was a major step up from the SE DVD. The DVD had a lot of digital noise while the Bluray has more detail and nice grain structure. Completely agree with RAH review.
 

Reggie W

Senior HTF Member
Joined
May 31, 2004
Messages
6,593
Location
Agua Verde
Real Name
Pike Bishop
I watched it last night and I have to admit with a film like this it is sometimes hard for me to nitpick the image when I am so caught up in the story. That said I had no complaints, could see grain present, did not think it looked overly manipulated but did recognize the "softness" of some shots. I chalked that up to the fact that is how the film always looked.

Add all this to the fact that this blu-ray of a classic "event" film can be had for $5.00 at Best Buy right now and less than $10.00 most everywhere else and I would think people would have no problem snapping this up.
 

Robert Harris

Archivist
Reviewer
Senior HTF Member
Joined
Feb 8, 1999
Messages
13,584
Real Name
Robert Harris
haineshisway said:
Glad to see this - as you know I wrote similar things yesterday in the other thread and a lengthy piece about it in my daily blog today.
Great minds...
 

FoxyMulder

映画ファン
Senior HTF Member
Joined
Sep 14, 2009
Messages
5,380
Location
Scotland
Real Name
Malcolm
So my question is this;

I was reading the "other" site about Torsten Kaiser receiving the same master for his TV broadcast work in 2011 as of course reported at the "other" site, so did the master he receive which was apparently de-noised by an outside vendor, that's according to Torsten and it seems also contrast boosted among other things, well back on point and to my basic question, does this blu ray release come from a different master to the one Torsten Kaiser used for broadcast or is this the basis for this blu ray release. ?

The review worries me, especially the remarks about it looking like a digital presentation, why can't it look more film like than digital, other releases do.
 

Torsten Kaiser

Film Restoration & Preservation
Insider
Joined
Nov 30, 2002
Messages
115
Real Name
Film Restoration & Preservation
FoxyMulder said:
So my question is this;

I was reading the "other" site about Torsten Kaiser receiving the same master for his TV broadcast work in 2011 as of course reported at the "other" site, so did the master he receive which was apparently de-noised by an outside vendor, that's according to Torsten and it seems also contrast boosted among other things, well back on point and to my basic question, does this blu ray release come from a different master to the one Torsten Kaiser used for broadcast or is this the basis for this blu ray release. ?

The review worries me, especially the remarks about it looking like a digital presentation, why can't it look more film like than digital, other releases do.
AGAIN - one more time:

[*]The author of the article in question used an interview (with another reviewer) which by now is almost 2 years old, and has ABSOLUTELY NO RELATION to the master of the Blu-ray WHATSOEVER.
[*]I was never asked whether my (old) comments could be used.
What is highly inapproriate, is that my comments were used despite that fact that these were solely regarding a completely different, High Definition master but were made to appear in the 2013 review of the new BD that they prove the point by the reviewer - i.e. that the product is bad. The catch is: I have never seen that BD or the new master, and my (old) comments were suggestively (mis)used by the author to "confirm" his arguments, something I utterly reject in both the way it was done and with regard to the content.

[*]The master used by MGM for the new Blu-ray is a new one, based on a 4K scan. Again, I have yet to see it.
[/list]
 

Lromero1396

Supporting Actor
Joined
Dec 19, 2012
Messages
640
Real Name
Leon Romero
Torsten Kaiser said:
AGAIN - one more time:

[*]The author of the article in question used an interview (with another reviewer) which by now is almost 2 years old, and has ABSOLUTELY NO RELATION to the master of the Blu-ray WHATSOEVER.
[*]I was never asked whether my (old) comments could be used.
What is highly inapproriate, is that my comments were used despite that fact that these were solely regarding a completely different, High Definition master but were made to appear in the 2013 review of the new BD that they prove the point by the reviewer - i.e. that the product is bad. The catch is: I have never seen that BD or the new master, and my (old) comments were suggestively (mis)used by the author to "confirm" his arguments, something I utterly reject in both the way it was done and with regard to the content.

[*]The master used by MGM for the new Blu-ray is a new one, based on a 4K scan. Again, I have yet to see it.
[/list]
Thank you, sir!
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Forum Sponsors

Latest Articles

Forum statistics

Threads
345,986
Messages
4,762,521
Members
141,626
Latest member
Sur
Top