Only a Blu-ray collection of all three films would cause me to give up the Laserdisc set. It is truly a beauty to behold. This collection along with the roadshow laserdiscs of THE ALAMO, HAWAII and the Pioneer disc of 1776 forces me to keep the laser player running.Matt Hough said:I still have the old laserdisc set of the three films (that box set offers the 1951 Show Boat in stereo; the DVD does not), and I routinely watch the 1936 and 1951 versions often. I'm not sure I've ever sat through the entire 1929 one. Might be a good idea to do that one of my off days.