Edward J M
Senior HTF Member
- Joined
- Sep 22, 2002
- Messages
- 2,031
This I'll take exception to.
Some people actually like the sound of harmonic distortion - subs that display high THD are often described as sounding "fuller, with more body and complexity". Well, in a way this is true, since the woofer cone is creating sounds of its own that are not present in the source signal.
Accuracy is the absence of deviation (in both frequency and distortion) from the source material. In any comparison, the sub which is most faithful to the source material is by definition the most accurate.
Professional testers have verified the two things common to the Sunfire products - a quick roll-off below 25 Hz, and prodigious amounts of distortion at frequencies below 30 Hz. These are not traits shared by SVS products.
In the end, one thing bears repeating: The most accurate reproduction of the source is not always what someone will prefer.
At a minimum, anyone considering a purchase should know ahead of time how the product in question performed in standardized and objective testing. If it tested out poorly, but they still liked it and bought it anyway, that's perfectly fine - at least they went into it with their eyes open and armed with the facts.