Arthur Powell
Supporting Actor
- Joined
- Feb 15, 2018
- Messages
- 574
- Real Name
- Arthur
I keep in mind something one of my grade school teachers said: Always read the book. Don't depend on the Disney version.
I keep in mind something one of my grade school teachers said: Always read the book. Don't depend on the Disney version.
Don't depend on the Disney version.
I don't think that she was implying necessarily that one is inferior to the other, but for the purposes of a book report, don't rely on the movie. In other words, don't pull a Beaver Cleaver You are right though in that you can't expect a 90 minute film to capture every iota of the source material. Ultimately, while it's inevitable for the film to be compared to the book, it should really be judged on its own merits.As is the case with any adaptation, that depends on your relationship to the novel. Just because a movie is different or takes considerable liberties with the source material does not automatically make the film inferior or invalid.
If you look at Disney's The Black Cauldron as it is, I think it works.
If you're comparing something to the source material, then obviously your perspective is different depending on your affection for the original source.
for the purposes of a book report, don't rely on the movie.
It always amazes me how stupid students think teachers are
As is the case with any adaptation, that depends on your relationship to the novel. Just because a movie is different or takes considerable liberties with the source material does not automatically make the film inferior or invalid.
...sounds like a 'splanation to the parentals for what all of the east coast teachers called "bad marks" ...'It’s an important learning experience. It’s a natural developmental thing to want to see how much you can get away with, and it’s important then to not get away with everything so you learn actions have consequences. Sometimes falling a paper or semester can be more important developmentally than getting an “A” would have been
It seems to me , that the “exclusive” format should be saved for films that deserve a Blu ray release but maybe aren’t popular enough to warrant a general release.
I'm almost tempted to buy the digital version to see if that will provoke Disney to announce a blu-ray! LOL! Next year marks the 55th anniversary so maybe Disney's fetish for anniversary editions may help us.I just hope to see The Happiest Millionaire come out on blu-ray.
Well, I'm bumping this thread because, almost a month later after I should have had it, the post office finally delivered my copy of The Black Cauldron today. Who knows where it has been since the tracking basically went up in smoke recently.
I had a similar problem.
That's Disney's usual MO. Relentless self-promotion so that the masses are brainwashed into thinking everything Disney touches is fabulous and they can do no wrong. Keeps everyone throwing money at them for every little bit of content.the biggest movie advertising lie of all time
"According to the Disney's Wonderful World episode "Disney Animation: The Illusion of Life", Mills was originally going to provide Eilonwy's voice in The Black Cauldron, but that role ended up being taken by Susan Sheridan."I never saw this film until home video, but the one thing I do remember about it is watching something about it on Disney's TV show, and at that point (it must have been early on in the process) they were promoting the fact that Hayley Mills was going to provide the voice of the female lead. I've never seen anything else about this, and now I'm wondering if memory is playing tricks on me. Does anyone else remember this?
Thank you! I see on imdb, Hayley Mills herself was the host of that 1981 episode:"According to the Disney's Wonderful World episode "Disney Animation: The Illusion of Life", Mills was originally going to provide Eilonwy's voice in The Black Cauldron, but that role ended up being taken by Susan Sheridan."