lark144
Senior HTF Member
- Joined
- Feb 22, 2012
- Messages
- 2,110
- Real Name
- mark gross
Hope I didn't come across as persnickety, as that was not at all my intention. You're absolutely correct, in terms of the subject matter being very un-Lubitsch, though I was concerned more with the emotional experience of watching the film. "The Man I Killed"--this was the original title, it was changed to "Broken Lullaby" on a later re-issue--was the first Lubitsch film I ever saw, and what surprised me was how close it was, stylistically and thematically, to his comedies, which I later saw. "The Man I Killed" was light in its camera movements, pacing and compositions, even though the subject matter was depressing. The comedies have plenty of melancholy undercurrents, while "The Man I Love" has moments that are almost humorous. And Nancy Carroll was luminous.A fair point, but yes, obviously, I was referring to the content, not the craftsmanship.