DVD Review HTF REVIEW: The Critic - The Complete Series

Discussion in 'DVD' started by Michael Osadciw, Jan 27, 2004.

  1. Michael Osadciw

    Michael Osadciw Screenwriter

    Jun 24, 2003
    Likes Received:
    Real Name:
    Michael Osadciw

    The Critic
    The Complete Series

    Studio: Columbia TriStar Home Entertainment
    Show Airings: 1994-1995

    Not Rated

    Film Length: 520 minutes
    Genre: TV - Animated Comedy

    Aspect Ratio: 1.33:1
    Audio: English Dolby Digital 2.0 Surround
    Subtitles: None
    Closed Captioned: Yes

    SLP: USD$49.95

    Release Date: January 27, 2004

    Show Rating [​IMG] [​IMG] [​IMG] [​IMG] / [​IMG] [​IMG] [​IMG] [​IMG] [​IMG]

    “IT STINKS!”

    …ok, I take that back, this show is far from stinky. But the glossy box holding the three disc set of the complete series of The Critic certainly has an odor I remember when I collected glossy hockey cards. While it didn’t generate the fan base like the long running animated series The Simpsons, The Critic was developed by the same producers and has much of the same charm as that show being a parody on films that stick in people’s heads. If you love watching film, I think you’ll love watching The Critic.

    There is a critic in every one of us. We have our opinions of what films are good and bad and this is how we can relate to Jay Sherman (voice of Jon Lovitz), a New York morning show movie critic who always seems to view the most horrible films, thus giving his most used line “It stinks!”. But as we all know, not everyone feels the same way. Aside from dissing actors and actresses, directors and producers, and not forgetting the networks too, Jay has his own critics. He’s not the most professional or attractive guy around - and people always point that out to him – he’s short and pudgy, and balding on top, accompanied with mannerisms of an animal when there is food around, and you can always find him picking the wax from his ear in the presence of females. Classy! To make matters worse, he’s an adopted son that can’t seem to get true affection from his foster parents, and his boss likes to make his life harder each day. Even his make-up artist puts him down! The only good thing in his life aside from his job is his son he shares with his estranged ex-wife. His son seems to go through a similar scenario as Jay as a child, but father knows best to help his 11-year-old son out.

    I’m happy to see The Critic arrive on DVD. This is one show I really wanted to see on DVD and I’m happy that Columbia TriStar has done a great job in bringing the complete series to our homes. There were 23 episodes total spanning two seasons in 1994-1995 and features the voices of Nancy Cartwright ("The Simpsons"), Christine Cavanaugh ("Rugrats") and Judith Ivey ("Designing Women"), plus special guest stars Billy Crystal, Geraldo Rivera, Kareem Abdul-Jabaar, Gene Siskel, June Lockhart, Margaret Cho, Milton Berle, Phil Hartman, Queen Latifah, Ricki Lake, Steve Allen, Adam West, Bob Costas, and Rod Steiger. The first season was aired on ABC and for the time was criticized for being to blunt and critical (go figure). Season two was aired on Fox, but after the show’s producers toned it down a bit the network wanted more satire from it. In the end, the show ceased after the 23rd episode. The show found its way back in the public eye five years later by means of the Internet with little animated shorts that are quite funny. These shorts are found in the special features menu. Below is a short synopsis of each season’s episode timing at approximately 23 min each.


    Jay is astounded when beautiful actress Valerie Fox takes a romantic interest in him. Despite
    warnings from his best friend, Australian actor Jeremy Hawke, that dating actresses is extremely
    dangerous, Jay begins an affair with the luscious Valerie.

    At a screening, Jay falls for a lovely young projectionist, not realizing she's actually an obsessed
    fan determined to make him her prisoner.

    Marty's First Date
    Jay's hints to his son Marty on how to romance a young woman have far-reaching consequences:
    the critic has to speed to Havana to rescue the lovesick lad, who has literally taken his father's
    advice and followed her home - to Cuba.

    Dial "M" for Mother
    Jay's attempt to show the world he can be warm by appearing with his mother on a talk show is a
    categorical failure he just can't find anything nice to say about her.

    A Little Deb Will Do Ya
    Jay's stepsister Margo reluctantly agrees to become a debutante and Jay's ratings are threatened
    by "Humphrey the Hippo," a children's show.

    Eye on the Prize
    After the failure of his 100th Episode Special and party, Jay is told that his TV show "Coming
    Attractions" is in trouble. It's time to take drastic measures.

    Every Doris Has Her Day
    Jay befriends and accidentally "dates" an older woman, make-up artist Doris, only to suspect she
    might be his biological mother.

    Marathon Mensch
    When an accidental fire breaks out in the studio during his TV show, Jay's whole audience
    watches as he panics and runs screaming from the set. Jay gamely struggles to reestablish his

    L.A. Jay
    In the wake of the positive response to a screenplay he has written, Jay takes a sabbatical from
    his show and joins Jeremy in Hollywood, where studio boss Gary Grossman agrees to buy it on
    the spot.

    Dr. Jay
    While at the Cannes Film Festival, Jay comes to the rescue when Duke is diagnosed with a
    terminal illness.

    A Day at the Races and a Night at the Opera
    Jay tries to help Marty overcome an inferiority complex by taking him to see his psychiatrist.

    Uneasy Rider
    Jay quits his show to become a truck driver after he's asked to promote Savvy Indian Chewing
    Tobacco on the show.

    A Pig-Boy and His Dog
    Inspired by her son's portly figure, Eleanor writes a children's book called The Fat Little Pig and
    Jay becomes a laughingstock.


    Sherman, Woman and Child
    Jay meets and falls for Alice, who gives him tips for improving his show to helps boost his poor

    Sherman of Arabia
    Jay recalls his heroines during the Gulf War while chaperoning a slumber party for Marty.

    A Song for Margo
    Jay's stepsister Margo is wooed by grunge rock star Johnny Wrath. Alice seeks help from Jay in
    finding the right school for Penny.

    From Chunk to Hunk
    Jay and Marty go to camp to lose weight and both discover that they are actually happier being

    Lady Hawke
    Alice is jealous when Jay is courted by Jeremy's beautiful sister, and Jay finds himself in the
    unusual position of having to choose between two women.

    Frankie and Ellie Get Lost
    Jay's parents disappear on their 40th anniversary vacation and Jay and Margo suddenly inherit
    their vast fortune.

    Siskel & Ebert & Jay & Alice
    When a popular movie reviewing team breaks up, Alice encourages Jay to audition to become
    the new partner.

    All the Duke's Men
    Jay is hired as a speechwriter when Duke runs for presidency and soon learns some grim truths
    about the world of politics.

    Alice's upstaging sister arrives in search of a rich husband and quickly turns her attention to Jay.

    I Can't Believe It's a Clip Show
    Jay is held hostage at Carnegie Hall while hosting his show's 10th-anniversary celebration.

    Video Quality? [​IMG] [​IMG] [​IMG] [​IMG] / [​IMG] [​IMG] [​IMG] [​IMG] [​IMG]

    This is not one of the sharpest animations to arrive on DVD. The source is inherently soft looking lacking defined edges around characters and objects. Season two looks much better than the first offering richer colours and a much brighter picture. The first season looks dim in comparison. The animation frequently shows grain and artifacts throughout with a little bit of DVD compression artifacts noticeable around edges. There is an occasional blurring effect present as if one was seeing “trails”…a similar effect to seeing a lag in fast motion on direct view LCD TVs. Thankfully there is no edge enhancement on the complete series aired for television, but the webisodes don’t escape from it, as there is a little bit of enhancement present. The webisodes animation is the most vibrant looking, but its animation is more limited and jerky looking for easy Internet downloading. In its original 4:3 aspect ratio, this is an average looking animated series, but it shouldn’t spoil the humor.

    Audio Quality? [​IMG] [​IMG] [​IMG] / [​IMG] [​IMG] [​IMG] [​IMG] [​IMG]

    There is a Dolby Surround 2.0 soundtrack on this series, and most of the audio is recorded in the center speaker. When there is music, it spreads to all channels (mono rear) and it’s recorded nicely, but quieter than the rest of the noise going on. The brief musical interludes sound as if they are trying not to be too intrusive on the program and seem recorded with mics far away from the performance. This is a quiet soundtrack with a few sounds used in the main channels to support on screen effects. I think more could have been done to heighten the experience of several scenes, but given this is a short-run adult animation series I’m sure this wasn’t a priority, nor was it to be expected.

    Special Features? [​IMG] [​IMG] [​IMG] / [​IMG] [​IMG] [​IMG] [​IMG] [​IMG]

    Each disc has its own set of special features, and surprisingly enough there is no mention of any special features on the packaging! I wonder who was in charge of the content on the back cover??!! I will tell you what features are found on these discs. You can expect commentaries spread across the three discs. They appear specifically on episodes 1, 2, 6, 7, 9, 13, 14, 15, and 20. There are different people participating in each commentary, and while some of it is interesting, a lot of times they can sit around and just watch the program and giggle at what they see. It wasn’t the most exciting thing to listen too. As a side note about commentaries, what I’m getting increasingly annoyed with these days is when I put a disc to watch a film or a program, we are forced to read the disclaimer about how Columbia TriStar does not take responsibility for what is said in the commentaries. This is something that can be skipped through with the skip button (because it comes up in French too), but I find it annoying when I have to see this when I don’t select the commentary option. While I agree that this notice should be posted, I think we should only have to see this screen IF THE COMMENTARY OPTION IS SELECTED. This way I can get to the film a lot faster in our busy little worlds. I feel better now that I’ve said that.

    Disc two special features has branching feature on the last episode that aired on ABC. A film reel pops up during the last two minutes of the epidode and by activating the ‘enter’ button we can access storyboard comparisons with commentary.

    The last disc has several more features over the other two discs. The first two features, Trailer Parodies (4m36s) and Top Ten List (6m23s) are clips of the film parodies throughout the series in DD2.0 stereo. Before you enter into each feature the feature sits you inside a movie theatre and fun facts are put up on the screen just as if you were waiting for a film to begin. Of course, a movie theatre wouldn’t be complete without Jay Sherman making loud noice crunching on his popcorn.

    Creating the Critic (11m49s) is a brief interview with several of the produces discussing the origin of the show and how characters were developed. We get to see some the the talent behind the animation.

    Finally, the last special feature on this disc (and the most funny one too) are the Webisodes. Since the show got the boot off Fox, Columbia seemed to pick up the rights for the ten webisodes. Each are about three and a half minutes each and are very saterical and fun to watch. The animation is pretty much web animation and its bright and colourful and in Dobly Digital 2.0 stereo. Only episode five seemed to have audio problems being quieter and sounding like its coming through a can.


    The Critic will find its way into many homes of parody lovers because there are some pretty good ones on this show. I’m happy to see the complete series released on DVD, and despite the animation looking a little rough, I’m happy with the overall quality of the set. Enjoy!

    Michael Osadciw
  2. Francois Caron

    Francois Caron Cinematographer

    Jul 31, 1997
    Likes Received:
    Real Name:
    Francois Caron
    I've never had the chance to watch this series when it originally aired (no cable), but I did see portions of it at times to know there was something unique about it. I'm definitely interested in purchasing this set!

    Good job Michael! You don't stink! [​IMG]
  3. Kenneth Cummings

    Kenneth Cummings Supporting Actor

    Aug 7, 2001
    Likes Received:
    Good review Michael. I was hoping the Critic was a good dvd, I as plan on picking up this week.

    You think that bad, you should see the disc for Fantasia. It has a disclaimer like this...before the commentary with Walt Disney!
  4. Matt_H

    Matt_H Stunt Coordinator

    Oct 22, 2003
    Likes Received:
    been wanting this since it was cancelled. I'm definetly getting it.
  5. Brian Thibodeau

    Brian Thibodeau Supporting Actor

    Dec 10, 2003
    Likes Received:
    Finally, a few more old VHS tapes ready for the pile!
  6. John Besse

    John Besse Supporting Actor

    Jun 22, 2000
    Likes Received:
    Trinity, FL
    Real Name:
    Damn, only 23 episodes [​IMG] I thought there were a lot more than that. However, I did watch the show when it was aired and loved it. Definitely a purchase... This is one expensive week for me in DVD releases!
  7. WillG

    WillG Producer

    Jan 30, 2003
    Likes Received:
    Anybody have any idea why there is no indication at all of any special features on the packaging. It seems pretty odd for a set with a fairly healthy array of extras.

    Although, this is CTHE we're talking about
  8. Jaime_Weinman

    Jaime_Weinman Supporting Actor

    Mar 19, 2001
    Likes Received:
    "Hava nageela, baby." This show was uneven -- as I recall, there were some episodes that suffered from bad pacing (long pauses after visual jokes; plots that kind of fizzled out in the third act), but the movie parodies were always funny, the characters were funny, and overall it was a terrific show -- sort of like what Family Guy would have been with competent writing.

    I once heard a rumor that Maurice LaMarche voiced Jay sometimes when Jon Lovitz couldn't come in to re-record dialogue -- do they address this on the commentaries? I know there was a "Pinky and the Brain" episode where LaMarche did a Lovitz impression and it was, indeed, dead-on.
  9. Casey Trowbridg

    Casey Trowbridg Lead Actor

    Apr 22, 2003
    Likes Received:
    I love this series, I quote it often even to this day, and so I can't wait to go pick this set up...
  10. Matt_H

    Matt_H Stunt Coordinator

    Oct 22, 2003
    Likes Received:
    they do adress the lovitz impersonation in the commentaryit's all lovitz except for belching
  11. Josh Sieg

    Josh Sieg Second Unit

    Oct 27, 2002
    Likes Received:
    I remember watching this when I was 10, they parodied beauty and the beast. "Beauty And King Dork".
  12. Matt_H

    Matt_H Stunt Coordinator

    Oct 22, 2003
    Likes Received:
    anybody want some dvd screenshots compared to screenshots of episodes taped off comedy central?
    Taped Episode:
    New DVD
  13. Eugene Esterly

    Eugene Esterly Supporting Actor

    Aug 7, 2002
    Likes Received:
    I will definetly be purchasing The Critic on DVD this year. This is one of my most request show on DVD. This show is excellent. I saw this show when it was new (on ABC then FOX) & I watched the reruns a lot several years ago on Comedy Central.
  14. Seth--L

    Seth--L Screenwriter

    Jun 22, 2003
    Likes Received:
    I just got the set today. I've listened to about half of the commentaries, and for the most part I think they're great. Very informative (it's rare that you get to hear people talk about why a show failed) and Maurice LaMarche is a riot.

    Quite a few times during the commentary he does his impression of Lovitz and it really is perfect.
  15. Dane Marvin

    Dane Marvin Screenwriter

    Jul 21, 2003
    Likes Received:
    Matt_H, thank you for the screen cap comparison!

    Agreed! I love his characters on Futurama!

Share This Page