Darby67
Screenwriter
- Joined
- Dec 4, 2009
- Messages
- 1,665
- Real Name
- Sean
The soundtracks were remixed into 5.1 for the original DVD releases, but only 2.0 stereo for the re-releases. While the dialog has been kept (mostly) to the center channel, music and effects have been expanded via “pseudo” stereo methods.@BobO'Link, or anyone else with the set, I have a question. Has the soundtrack been done in a fake stereo like record companies used to do with albums in the old days? I've been watching YouTube uploads of the show and it seems the majority of them are false stereo, at least the theme song.
I've not yet opened the set but on the back is this:@BobO'Link, or anyone else with the set, I have a question. Has the soundtrack been done in a fake stereo like record companies used to do with albums in the old days? I've been watching YouTube uploads of the show and it seems the majority of them are false stereo, at least the theme song.
The ones on YouTube are fake stereo. I keep my home theater set to 5.1 Dolby Pro-Logic, so I don't have any way (that I know of) of setting it to mono. I kept noticing a response from all 5 speakers when it should be center only.I've not yet opened the set but on the back is this:
"English Dolby digital mono"
That same blurb is on the back of all 6 seasons from Shout.
**EDIT**
I opened my S2 set, started episode 1, and placed myself squarely between the speakers. The audio is absolutely mono. No fake stereo. That includes the theme song. Since S2 is presented in mono, as the blurb on the back of the case states, I can see no reason the rest are not also properly in mono since they, too, state this on the back of the case.
Well, I can’t speak to Shout’s season 2 since I have the original seasons 1-3 from Goldhill Media which are 5.1. But I do have Shout’s season 4 which is definitely stereo enhanced. I haven’t had a chance to pick up seasons 5-6 yet.I've not yet opened the set but on the back is this:
"English Dolby digital mono"
That same blurb is on the back of all 6 seasons from Shout.
**EDIT**
I opened my S2 set, started episode 1, and placed myself squarely between the speakers. The audio is absolutely mono. No fake stereo. That includes the theme song. Since S2 is presented in mono, as the blurb on the back of the case states, I can see no reason the rest are not also properly in mono since they, too, state this on the back of the case.
**EDIT #2**
Since I also own copies of this series in the original Liberation release I got S2 of that set out and played the same episode. The 5.1 mix sounds louder and absolutely has some separation. The English stereo track is less pronounced but still has some stereo presence. The Spanish stereo track has almost the same sound as does the 5.1 mix and is a bit wider than the English stereo mix. All three of those sound different than the mono mix on the Shout release.
It's possible the Fox set uses those 2.0 channel "stereo" mixes but I've not seen the back of that case nor have copies of that one to check.
If the Shout release has any added foley effects they're inconsequential and, at least to me, so far unnoticeable.
As I stated about S1, the video looks to be identical to the Liberation S2 set although with a slightly higher bit rate. It looks fairly good at a normal viewing distance but don't get too close or you'll see anomalies.
My setup is stereo only. I very much dislike surround sound and prefer my audio to come from where the image originates.The ones on YouTube are fake stereo. I keep my home theater set to 5.1 Dolby Pro-Logic, so I don't have any way (that I know of) of setting it to mono. I kept noticing a response from all 5 speakers when it should be center only.
Interesting. The information display on my player shows the audio is "Dolby Digital Stereo" but there are absolutely no stereo effects or separation of any kind that I can hear. It's absolutely dead center.Well, I can’t speak to Shout’s season 2 since I have the original seasons 1-3 from Goldhill Media which are 5.1. But I do have Shout’s season 4 which is definitely stereo enhanced. I haven’t had a chance to pick up seasons 5-6 yet.