DaViD Boulet
Senior HTF Member
- Joined
- Feb 24, 1999
- Messages
- 8,826
It's been noted by many that if consumers could simply buy affordable universal "combo" HD players that could play both Blu-ray and HD DVD discs with equal aplomb, that the consequences of a "format war" would essentially be moot. The distinction between Blu-ray and HD DVD media would be no different than the choices that DVD developers have today between single or double layer DVD, DVD-18 etc. If a studio wanted to use a high-bit-rate 50 gig platter for a full-out A-title special edition they'd use Blu-ray Disc. If they wanted to save money to replicate a music-video that didn't place demands on bit-rate or storage capacity they'd use HD DVD. What would it really matter if the disc would play in everyone's "high def" player? Both disc media types could become viable formats side-by-side, and content providers could choose which disc structure to utilize based on program-authoring needs.
The real problem has been that the cost increase of a "dual format" universal player would offset the advantage for many consumers. But what if providing *both* BD *and* HD DVD full functionality only added a few dollars to the final price of an HD disc player? It would seem that most hardware manufacturers might stand to gain an advantage offering this expanded functionality to the consumer (though I wouldn't expect to see Sony or Toshiba combo-players for some time )
I came across this at DVD file and think it's an interesting development:
http://www.dvdfile.com/index.php?opt...=5356&Itemid=5
The real problem has been that the cost increase of a "dual format" universal player would offset the advantage for many consumers. But what if providing *both* BD *and* HD DVD full functionality only added a few dollars to the final price of an HD disc player? It would seem that most hardware manufacturers might stand to gain an advantage offering this expanded functionality to the consumer (though I wouldn't expect to see Sony or Toshiba combo-players for some time )
I came across this at DVD file and think it's an interesting development:
http://www.dvdfile.com/index.php?opt...=5356&Itemid=5