- Joined
- Jul 3, 1997
- Messages
- 66,795
- Real Name
- Ronald Epstein
This shows you why Hollywood was the Dream Factory as a whole especially MGM - "The Clock"One of the best romance movies from the 1940s.
And don't forget A Star is Born. The film she should have won Best Actress for. The bad timing of Grace Kelly announcing her retirement from Hollywood killed that.I always considered The Clock a startling departure for Garland. She truly was a superior actress who could have had a dramatic career, proving it decades later with A Child is Waiting, I Could Go On Singing, and, of course, her exquisitely careworn cameo as Irene Hoffman in Judgment at Nuremburg. The Clock is an early example of the depth of Judy's strengths as a dramatic actress. I never felt Robert Walker was her equal here - good as he is elsewhere in his own career. Still, can't wait to have this in hi-def - at last.
What the craftsmen at the studios were able to create for these films is truly remarkable. After having lived in NYC for many years, Minnelli said his intention was to make NYC the third character in this film and I believe he succeeded. Beautiful film and looking forward to the upgrade.The most realistic sets that were created on a backlot. That this film was not shot in New York is amazing. The set for Penn station seems to be a record of a great landmark that was torn down in the early 1960's. Only its not. Its a set bullt just for this picture.
A Star Is Born is the one movie where I feel Judy's talents as a dramatic star as well as a musical performer collided to create the perfect storm of a legendary performance. Don't get me wrong. I love Grace Kelly. But she didn't win this one on merit.And don't forget A Star is Born. The film she should have won Best Actress for. The bad timing of Grace Kelly announcing her retirement from Hollywood killed that.
No Flowers in sight, but hopefully we’ll get to hear the Stems.[…]No Bess Flowers strangely enough, but we do get Kenner G. Kemp.
I got a kick out of seeing Moyna MacGill at the drug store counter. She really does have a very strong resemblance to her daughter Angela Lansbury.If you can trust the IMDb listing, half the population of Hollywood extras, bit players and character actors worked on this film. No Bess Flowers strangely enough, but we do get Kenner G. Kemp.
Grace Kelly did not meet Rainier until after her Oscar win. Any plans for retirement came some time after her win. Her cinematic popularity, her box office earnings, the incredible run of films she had released in ‘54 (Rear Window, Dial M for Murder, The Country Girl), and her first major dramatic turn likely all played a part in her winning. Garland’s troubled history with Hollywood (of which she was the victim- not placing any blame on her) likely played a defining role in her loss. They weren’t about to reward someone who they felt had behaved badly and thus been punished with termination just four-five years earlier. Hollywood- what a great town.And don't forget A Star is Born. The film she should have won Best Actress for. The bad timing of Grace Kelly announcing her retirement from Hollywood killed that.
Grace Kelly did not meet Rainier until after her Oscar win. Any plans for retirement came some time after her win. Her cinematic popularity, her box office earnings, the incredible run of films she had released in ‘54 (Rear Window, Dial M for Murder, The Country Girl), and her first major dramatic turn likely all played a part in her winning. Garland’s troubled history with Hollywood (of which she was the victim- not placing any blame on her) likely played a defining role in her loss. They weren’t about to reward someone who they felt had behaved badly and thus been punished with termination just four-five years earlier. Hollywood- what a great town.
Frankly, I thought Bette Davis was better than both of them in "The Letter". That same year, James Stewart winning Best Actor over Henry Fonda was a travesty to me. Stewart's is viewed as a makeup Oscar for not winning for Mr. Smith Goes to Washington and the same for Fontaine winning for Suspicion. Anyhow, there are plenty of such Oscar snubs, including actors not even getting nominated for iconic roles such as Robert Mitchum as Harry Powell and John Wayne as Ethan Edwards.Not sure why the Academy gave it to Grace over Garland. But it is one of those epic Oscar snubs for which no explanation will suffice. Another is Ginger Rogers winning Best Actress for Kitty Foyle over Joan Fontaine in Rebecca (1940....awards handed out in 1941).
Agree with Davis for The Letter. Forgot about her in that, actually. Sacrilege. Fontaine should never have won it for Suspicion.Frankly, I thought Bette Davis was better than both of them in "The Letter". That same year, James Stewart winning Best Actor over Henry Fonda was a travesty to me. Stewart's is viewed as a makeup Oscar for not winning for Mr. Smith Goes to Washington and the same for Fontaine winning for Suspicion. Anyhow, there are plenty of such Oscar snubs, including actors not even getting nominated for iconic roles such as Robert Mitchum as Harry Powell and John Wayne as Ethan Edwards.
Another theory for Kelly's win over Garland that I've read is that she had two studio's voting blocs routing for her, MGM where she was under contract and Paramount where she made The Country Girl. Still a travesty.Grace Kelly did not meet Rainier until after her Oscar win. Any plans for retirement came some time after her win. Her cinematic popularity, her box office earnings, the incredible run of films she had released in ‘54 (Rear Window, Dial M for Murder, The Country Girl), and her first major dramatic turn likely all played a part in her winning. Garland’s troubled history with Hollywood (of which she was the victim- not placing any blame on her) likely played a defining role in her loss. They weren’t about to reward someone who they felt had behaved badly and thus been punished with termination just four-five years earlier. Hollywood- what a great town.
Mitchum as Henry Powell. A huge bravo for bringing that Oscar snub to the fore.Frankly, I thought Bette Davis was better than both of them in "The Letter". That same year, James Stewart winning Best Actor over Henry Fonda was a travesty to me. Stewart's is viewed as a makeup Oscar for not winning for Mr. Smith Goes to Washington and the same for Fontaine winning for Suspicion. Anyhow, there are plenty of such Oscar snubs, including actors not even getting nominated for iconic roles such as Robert Mitchum as Harry Powell and John Wayne as Ethan Edwards.