Todd McF
Second Unit
- Joined
- Jul 5, 2001
- Messages
- 285
I watched this for the fifth time yesterday, and my wife and I agree on what we think is the critical weakness of the film that leaves it, tragically, so flat.
Its not the story. The story is there. Yeah, Jar Jar is a pest and the Jedi characters and the Queen where not developed - at all really - but there is something worse:
Anikan's mother can't act and it destroys the audiences only real emotional link to Anikan.
The audience is *supposed* to feel Anikan's heart whenching departure from his mother and eagerly anticipate his return to free the slaves (Episode 2?). Unfortunately for me, I could care less if I ever see his mother again because she has the emotional level of drift wood.
Look at Star Wars for contrast: the audience was linked to Luke because we
1. Felt his regret at having never met his real father
2. Sympathized with his desire to "get involved" and ultimately become a Jedi, like his father.
During the "dinner scene" at Anikan's house his mothers awful acting quality is nothing short of debilitating for the film. I swear I saw here reading off of cue cards. At least Luke whined convincingly.
Any comments?
- Todd
Its not the story. The story is there. Yeah, Jar Jar is a pest and the Jedi characters and the Queen where not developed - at all really - but there is something worse:
Anikan's mother can't act and it destroys the audiences only real emotional link to Anikan.
The audience is *supposed* to feel Anikan's heart whenching departure from his mother and eagerly anticipate his return to free the slaves (Episode 2?). Unfortunately for me, I could care less if I ever see his mother again because she has the emotional level of drift wood.
Look at Star Wars for contrast: the audience was linked to Luke because we
1. Felt his regret at having never met his real father
2. Sympathized with his desire to "get involved" and ultimately become a Jedi, like his father.
During the "dinner scene" at Anikan's house his mothers awful acting quality is nothing short of debilitating for the film. I swear I saw here reading off of cue cards. At least Luke whined convincingly.
Any comments?
- Todd