Chris Will
Screenwriter
I think this backlash proves one thing, as much as some fans say they want new things, they really just want more of the same. Some one even posted earlier here that TLJ goes against established patterns for the series. That's actually way I love it so much. TLJ genuinely surprised and shocked me more than any other movie in the series sense TESB.
I'll never understand this need for backstory and for everything to have an answer these days. IMO, the PT ruins some of the fun of the OT by spelling everything out. After ANH, did we really need to know how Vader came to power? Obi-wan said he was "seduced by the darkside". Why can't that be enough, it was enough for me when I was a kid? Plus, what I imagined as a kid, of Anakin Skywalker fighting along side of Obi-wan in the Clone Wars, was far more exciting and fun than what Lucas ended up putting on the screen.
Rey's parents was always going to upset a group of fans depending on which theory you decided to support. I never liked the idea of her being a Skywalker or a Solo so, being a nobody was the perfect answer in my book. It makes her character feel more real. JJ could always come back and change this in IX and, honestly, it wouldn't surprise me if he did.
The biggest complaints I see from people are about TFA mysteries not being answered in a way they wanted. Maybe JJ just needs to stop using his mystery box belief in everything he makes.
I'll never understand this need for backstory and for everything to have an answer these days. IMO, the PT ruins some of the fun of the OT by spelling everything out. After ANH, did we really need to know how Vader came to power? Obi-wan said he was "seduced by the darkside". Why can't that be enough, it was enough for me when I was a kid? Plus, what I imagined as a kid, of Anakin Skywalker fighting along side of Obi-wan in the Clone Wars, was far more exciting and fun than what Lucas ended up putting on the screen.
Rey's parents was always going to upset a group of fans depending on which theory you decided to support. I never liked the idea of her being a Skywalker or a Solo so, being a nobody was the perfect answer in my book. It makes her character feel more real. JJ could always come back and change this in IX and, honestly, it wouldn't surprise me if he did.
The biggest complaints I see from people are about TFA mysteries not being answered in a way they wanted. Maybe JJ just needs to stop using his mystery box belief in everything he makes.