- Joined
- Jul 3, 1997
- Messages
- 66,880
- Real Name
- Ronald Epstein
Glad to hear from you Joe! So pleased your wonderful commentary with Peter will be released again.
I concur. It's good to see you here, Joe!
Glad to hear from you Joe! So pleased your wonderful commentary with Peter will be released again.
Now we just need to work to get the Director's Cut of Texasville you produced released again as well! Hopefully the digression will be allowed - I found when comparing the two versions that some alternate takes were used for your LD version - Do you recall if those shots were used to avoid the jumpcuts in the negative for the theatrical cut or more because Peter Bogdanovich preferred the alternate takes?I concur. It's good to see you here, Joe!
Yes, that is correct. My mistake.No Jack, it was removed for the 2002 DVD, the original Director's Cut
There's so much missing from the theatrical version that I probably couldn't bear to watch it again other than as a curiosity.
Do you mean the main titles? The overture is only in the LD. Fun bit of trivia if you watch the LD cut you’ll see there are outtakes of going down the stairs that are the edited out head and tail of the shots because the only version they had of the correct shot had titles on. The sound of his footsteps therefore doesn’t match.I’ll pick this up in time for July 4th and watch the original theatrical version this year rather than the extended version.
One thing I did love in the theatrical version was the lack of an overture, and how the film opens cold on the bell tower. Adams is summoned, he makes a sarcastic joke, and then the main titles appear as he runs down the stairs and into the congressional session. That run down the stairs has always seemed excessively long to me without the credits, and I think the lack of the credits has a way of stepping on that joke by giving it too much room to breathe.
Yeah I agree Josh, I’ve seen the film hundreds of times but I’ve never seen this cut in widescreen. Also there are a few shots that are exclusive to this version, places where PHH went to closeups for his cut, like just before Martha comes down the stairs.I doubt it’ll re-emerge as my go-to version but I’m eager to see it as I first did, only in widescreen rather than pan & scan.
If memory serves (always a question), the theatrical is still in the neighborhood of 140 minutes so it’s still quite a long film either way. I’ll miss Cool Considerate Men. If I want an “accurate to the 7th grade classroom” version to recreate my first middle school viewing, then I will need to fast forward through Molasses To Rum and any Jeffersonian romance.
Two minutes is the difference in two cuts?
I played Caesar Rodney the first time I did 1776 on the stage, and I have to say a good portion of that role is missing from the theatrical cut, too. Another reason I don't prefer it.I doubt it’ll re-emerge as my go-to version but I’m eager to see it as I first did, only in widescreen rather than pan & scan.
If memory serves (always a question), the theatrical is still in the neighborhood of 140 minutes so it’s still quite a long film either way. I’ll miss Cool Considerate Men. If I want an “accurate to the 7th grade classroom” version to recreate my first middle school viewing, then I will need to fast forward through Molasses To Rum and any Jeffersonian romance.
I played Caesar Rodney the first time I did 1776 on the stage, and I have to say a good portion of that role is missing from the theatrical cut, too. Another reason I don't prefer it.
He had cancer that had manifested itself on his face, so it was to cover it.He is one of the more interesting characters in the film. I remember he's brought back for the signing and you can see that his health has significantly declined.
What was the deal with his facial brace?
Shhh we don’t want to wait longer! I’d bet it has to do with tight replication windows and they want to be sure it doesn’t come out post 7/4My wife watches this film every July 4th. She had it on VHS, then on DVD, then we upgraded to the BD. Now UHD. She hasn't seen the theatrical version since the 1970s (on a school field trip, presumably during the Bicentennial; she's a little too young to have seen it in 1972), and hasn't ever seen the LD version. To have all four versions in one place is heaven for her.
I'm just surprised that they're releasing this at the end of May, rather than the week of July 4th (or the week before).
One of Warner’s peeves was the Delaware delegation. He thought they were too comical.I played Caesar Rodney the first time I did 1776 on the stage, and I have to say a good portion of that role is missing from the theatrical cut, too. Another reason I don't prefer it.
We're talking about 2 minutes difference, right? What is in those 2 minutes?