- Joined
- May 9, 2003
- Messages
- 3,103
I don't think O'Bannon had any problem with Ripley being female, or with Sigourney Weaver playing the part.
I agree with you that the addition of Ash is a good thing for the movie - without it, the movie would be a fairly linear matter of the alien getting on board, attacking the crew and then being thrown out. With Ash, the story becomes more complicated, and more interesting.
I've never had any issue with the veracity of O'Bannon's statements. I think he could be a curmudgeon about a lot of it, but I didn't get the impression that he was making untrue statements. What I saw as a throughline in his statements all the way from 1979 up to the 2000s was a combination of pride in his work, dissatisfaction in the way he was treated by Giler and Hill, and frustration that he thought that Hill was trying to take credit for his work. And this was a fairly civilized response, I should add. Imagine what would have happened had the movie been originally written by Harlan Ellison...
I agree with you that the addition of Ash is a good thing for the movie - without it, the movie would be a fairly linear matter of the alien getting on board, attacking the crew and then being thrown out. With Ash, the story becomes more complicated, and more interesting.
I've never had any issue with the veracity of O'Bannon's statements. I think he could be a curmudgeon about a lot of it, but I didn't get the impression that he was making untrue statements. What I saw as a throughline in his statements all the way from 1979 up to the 2000s was a combination of pride in his work, dissatisfaction in the way he was treated by Giler and Hill, and frustration that he thought that Hill was trying to take credit for his work. And this was a fairly civilized response, I should add. Imagine what would have happened had the movie been originally written by Harlan Ellison...