What's new

HTF REVIEW: "Roots" 25th Anniversary Edition (1 Viewer)

Ronald Epstein

Founder
Owner
Moderator
Senior HTF Member
Joined
Jul 3, 1997
Messages
66,791
Real Name
Ronald Epstein
23269.jpg


ROOTS

"The ancestors of all of us came across
that same ocean in some ship. We must learn
not only to live together, but learn to see
one another as people rather than stereotypes."

-Alex Haley-
I love Father John Banahan's quote inside the
packaging of this newly released 3-disc set that
so rightfully describes the impact of the Roots saga:
"An Experience similar to watching the first men
walk on the moon". Amen, Father!
On January 23rd 1977, Roots made television
history. 103 million people witnessed master
storyteller Alex Haley's chronicles of
his own family across many generations, from
the kidnapping of an African warrior by American
slave traders to eventual post-Civil War freedom.
His family became our family. They were characters
that became part of the American language and national
consciousness.
The series ultimately garnered 9 Emmy Awards
including Best Limited Series.
Warner has packaged this landmark series in
a cardboard package with slipcase insert that
slides out and opens into a 5-gatefold that
features 3 DVDs housed in plastic. The insert
has the full index of each 2-sided DVD broken
down by chapters. There is also a text breakdown
of all the contributors (Directors, Producers, etc.)
on each disc as well as those that provided
running audio commentary.
Starting with Disc One/SideA, we are greeted by
a non-animated standard menu. The viewer has the
option of watching Roots with running
commentary from a wealth of contributors including
David L. Wopler, Levar Burton and
Cicely Tyson, as well as the Directors
and screenwriters that put it all together.
There is also running VIDEO commentary. This
was an option I had a problem with. Allegedly, a
ROOTS LOGO appears in the corner of your screen
during various points of the presentation that lets
you open a window that shows you the individual
giving the running audio commentary. Most of the first
two discs that I scanned through for this review
failed to show that logo. I was able to watch
HIGHLIGHTS of the video commentary through
the Commentary Video Highlights option off
the Main Menu.
How does the video look and audio sound?
In general, the video looks good, though not
pristine. The video is often littered with small
amounts of dirt and an excessive amount of grain.
Colors look faded, and the overall feel of the
presentation looks dated as a result. Perhaps
this works to the advantage of a story of its time
period. Overall, I don't think anyone is going to
be terribly unhappy with the video quality.
It was very nice to see that the original broadcast
ROOTS introduction was included in this release (which
is shown just prior to the start of the first
episode). I believe this was omitted from the
VHS versions that have been previously available.
While the audio is presented MONO (as originally
broadcast in 1977), it sounds generally good.
I actually had the opportunity to listen to
much of the running commentary on Disc 1. If you
have already previously seen Roots, I would
opt to start watching it immediately with commentary.
Producer Frank L. Wolper talks about how he
approached Columbia and Warner brothers about the
original project. Levar Burton talks about
how he never wanted to get into TV and film and
was a drama student at USC when he was approached
to do Roots. He talks about the awe of
working with acting royalty. Ed Asner gives
some very stern insight into the black hole of
slavery and how it became the economic staple of
the new world.
Remembering Roots is a collage of recent
interviews with the principle actors, actresses
and Producers/Directors done exclusively for this
DVD. Ed Asner, Sandy Duncan, Cicely Tyson,
Levar Burton, Georg Stanford Brown, Beverly Todd,
John Amos as well as the many writers and
Directors contribute their thoughts on what Roots
means to them and this generation. There is also
a segment where each actor gives their rememberences
of Alex Haley.
Finally, a simple Family Tree traces the
Haley family back to its ancestoral roots.
Final Thoughts
Never before nor after had a miniseries made such
an impact on everyone that was witness to it. This
was a story that made us laugh, cry, and even rage
with anger.
Warner Brothers has done an admirable job of
bringing this series to DVD. The amount of
interview material from the surviving actors
and contributors who participated in this DVD
presentation shows the monstrous effort that
the studio went to in order to preserve the
integrity of this series.
This is a DVD that belongs in every collection.
Do not hesitate to purchase it.
Release Date: January 15, 2001
 

Nigel W

Grip
Joined
Nov 24, 2000
Messages
23
I plan to add this to my collection and have been anxiously awaiting its release.

I was too young to watch this when it originally aired, but will jump into every aspect of this series once I get it.

It's good to hear that Warner has done a fine job on this series!
 

Jeff_A

Screenwriter
Joined
Mar 6, 2001
Messages
1,454
Thanks for the great review, Ron. It appears there are some very interesting extras as well. Does the packaging appear rather fragile like The Godfather Collection?
Regardless, I am all over this one. :)
 

Ronald Epstein

Founder
Owner
Moderator
Senior HTF Member
Joined
Jul 3, 1997
Messages
66,791
Real Name
Ronald Epstein
I had forgotten that the series ran 8 nights.

They cut it down to 6 episodes. What this

does to the continuity or even the "Last On..."

recap that is done at the start of each episode,

I don't know.

The packaging is on the frail side. It's

basically thin cardboard with plastic hubs to

house the DVDs.
 

Anthony_H

Stunt Coordinator
Joined
Apr 27, 2000
Messages
231
Location
Sherman Texas
Real Name
Anthony
Ron;

Could you please clarify? Did you mean "cut it down" as in excluding any of the original broadcast material? Or simply condensed the original eight parts into six?
 

ScottR

Senior HTF Member
Joined
Apr 1, 2000
Messages
2,646
When Roots originally aired, four nights ran two hours and four nights ran one hour. The episodes were condensed for home video, and now dvd. Nothing has been cut, with the exception of the opening and ending credits for some of the hour long episodes (unless ABC simply re-ran the credits.) What I am confused about is this- Warner claims that the mini-series is taken from the original elements. If they went through the trouble to include the original bumpers and introduction, why then are they showing it in 6 parts? Was it originally in six parts, and then the network cut it down, or is the dvd taken from a later-'70's re-broadcast. I really wish the studios could be more specific with their claims when they say that something is "restored and remastered from the original elements." Elements taken from 1978, or later, are not the original elements, but dupes.
 

ScottR

Senior HTF Member
Joined
Apr 1, 2000
Messages
2,646
By the way, Episodes 3 and 5 were the ones that were seen in hour-long installments.
 

Glenise

Supporting Actor
Joined
Feb 5, 2001
Messages
773
I went to Best Buy to purchase "Roots" today and they were sold out.

I had to get a rain check.
 

Glenn Overholt

Senior HTF Member
Joined
Mar 24, 1999
Messages
4,201
Let's see. 4 x 2 + 4 x 1 = 12 hours. (How's that for some fast and easy math?) 12 hours of air time with commericals would come to about 9 hours without them. That's 540 minutes. The box says 573 minutes. (Ok, shoot me, my commercial time is off!)

I'd have to assume that this set includes the whole 9 yards. I hope I'm right.

Glenn
 

ScottR

Senior HTF Member
Joined
Apr 1, 2000
Messages
2,646
Glenn, the entire mini-series is included as far as the story..I am not sure about opening and ending credits and previews for the extra two episodes. I'll bet when it originally aired, it was cut up by ABC, with the last hour of each one hour segment run without a preview...and the end credits for the one hour episodes run twice. Who knows. What a wacky way to present a movie.
 

Mikah Cerucco

Senior HTF Member
Joined
Nov 27, 1998
Messages
2,457
Everything is there, though I haven't watched my set yet.
I agree every collection should contain these DVD's. It is one of the things I've most been looking forward too (more than even Star Wars and BTTF, for instance). I was hoping they'd do the set while the principals were still alive.
I taped the 25th Anniversary Special broadcast on NBC this past Friday (1/18/2002) as I wasn't sure it was included on the DVD. I made a VCD of it to keep with the package.
I've never seen this with Closed Captions before, so I'll really enjoy watching it again.
Ron, thanks for reviewing this. I hadn't seen much about it either here or in alt.video.dvd and it really does deserve some attention. Of course all the ads during the recent 25th anniversary celebration won't hurt. :)
 

Glenn Overholt

Senior HTF Member
Joined
Mar 24, 1999
Messages
4,201
Ok Scott, maybe that came out wrong. If a 2 hour show airs on TV, there will be about 30 minutes of commercials. Since each side of each disk is a little over an hour and a half, the four one hour episodes would have some of the opening and ending credits removed so that they won't show up in the middle of a disk, (which would look a little silly, IMO). With the 'naturally' occuring spaces for commercials, it wouldn't be any problem to end a disk in the middle of an episode, and continue it after the opening credits on the next DVD. (I'm being as confusing as I possibly can on this - is it working?).

You did have a question and I think I answered it.

Glenn
 

ScottR

Senior HTF Member
Joined
Apr 1, 2000
Messages
2,646
Guys, here is what I feel happened. All of the episodes are complete as far as content is concerned, and each disc ends at the end of an episode with complete credits. The one-hour episodes were part of episodes 3 and 5. The opening credits for the first hour are there, along with previews from the previous episode. On DVD, the episode ends after what would have been two, one-hour episodes, with the credits. Perhaps the credits weren't condensed on dvd, and the original broadcast simply re-ran the same credits for episodes 3& 4 twice. To make matters even more complicated, the recap following what would have been a one hour episode contains scenes from both one hour episodes before it. I think ABC hacked this one into 8 pieces at the last minute. I wish I could verify this as it has bugged me for eight years now.
 

Scott_G

Second Unit
Joined
Jun 18, 2000
Messages
268
I just got mine from outpost.com. $35 shipped.
My 10 year old is doing a school paper on slavery. This should help him out.
to my wife ...
I told you the HT would be educational :D
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Sign up for our newsletter

and receive essential news, curated deals, and much more







You will only receive emails from us. We will never sell or distribute your email address to third party companies at any time.

Forum statistics

Threads
357,064
Messages
5,129,891
Members
144,282
Latest member
Feetman
Recent bookmarks
0
Top