CRyan
Screenwriter
- Joined
- Feb 9, 1999
- Messages
- 1,239
Well, I just don't know anymore. Here is the deal.
I had an auction for a DVD movie.
The title of the auction had the name of the DVD with the word "New" at the end.
In the item description, I gave information about the DVD release (5.1, widescreen, etc.) and ended my listing with a statement regarding the quality of the DVD.
It said, "Packaging and Disc in MINT condition (perfect)!"
The high bidder payed me three days following auction end and I mailed his DVD the next day. He recieved the DVD and has now complained that the DVD is not factory sealed.
I, however, never said that the DVD was factory sealed - nor implied it. Our business had purchased quite a few DVD's that were opened and then stored - never viewed and the cases were never even opened. We are just getting around to reselling them now on ebay.
So, what is the deffinition of new when dealing with an auction. I always see auctions for DVD's that say "new and factory sealed" or "brand new, still shrinkwrapped." I thought new meant not used.
I was NOT attempting to be misleading - I just stated the fact that the item was new. In fact, the only time I said "new" was in the title. The rest of the auction was about the DVD release itself and ending with the statement mentioned above (Mint Condition).
So does the statement "NEW" in an auction imply that the item is still factory sealed? Even most stores, in their return policies, state that DVD's must still be "new and unopened" in order to return. So it seems that new does not really mean unopened.
What are your thoughts?
Oh, and I am going to allow this person to return this auction item. He says it is for a gift and he cannot give an opened gift. I am trying to avoid negatvie feedback here, which I still may get after this is all over if he is so inclined. BTW, this buyer has a very positive feedback rating with no negatives.
Thanks for any feedback,
C. Ryan
I had an auction for a DVD movie.
The title of the auction had the name of the DVD with the word "New" at the end.
In the item description, I gave information about the DVD release (5.1, widescreen, etc.) and ended my listing with a statement regarding the quality of the DVD.
It said, "Packaging and Disc in MINT condition (perfect)!"
The high bidder payed me three days following auction end and I mailed his DVD the next day. He recieved the DVD and has now complained that the DVD is not factory sealed.
I, however, never said that the DVD was factory sealed - nor implied it. Our business had purchased quite a few DVD's that were opened and then stored - never viewed and the cases were never even opened. We are just getting around to reselling them now on ebay.
So, what is the deffinition of new when dealing with an auction. I always see auctions for DVD's that say "new and factory sealed" or "brand new, still shrinkwrapped." I thought new meant not used.
I was NOT attempting to be misleading - I just stated the fact that the item was new. In fact, the only time I said "new" was in the title. The rest of the auction was about the DVD release itself and ending with the statement mentioned above (Mint Condition).
So does the statement "NEW" in an auction imply that the item is still factory sealed? Even most stores, in their return policies, state that DVD's must still be "new and unopened" in order to return. So it seems that new does not really mean unopened.
What are your thoughts?
Oh, and I am going to allow this person to return this auction item. He says it is for a gift and he cannot give an opened gift. I am trying to avoid negatvie feedback here, which I still may get after this is all over if he is so inclined. BTW, this buyer has a very positive feedback rating with no negatives.
Thanks for any feedback,
C. Ryan