LeoA
Senior HTF Member
I didn't scan the entire list (Basically just the bottom 20 and the top 20), but I was surprised to see 'The Ballad of the Betty Lou' and 'The Death of the Party' ranked so low. While not up there with the greatest episodes of the show, I feel like they're both above average.
And 'Long Night’s Journey Into Day' is a top 10 episode for me. Definitely not 83rd best for me.
I just watched the "nobody knows how I feel" episode a few nights ago.
Always been disappointed that his episodes hadn't turned out better. I think they perhaps even realized it at the time that they were somewhat weak, since this particular episode was left wide open for a follow-up episode involving his marriage with Julie. Yet that was the end of it all and we never hear from Stacey Petrie again after that two part season 4 episode.
And the sleepwalking one that introduced Rob's brother to us a season or two earlier should've been one of the all-time great sitcom episodes. A Dick Van Dyke Show episode that involves sleepwalking sounds like a match made in heaven for a great sitcom like this. But the end result ended up merely okay rather than a classic.
His four appearances definitely were a missed opportunity. Jerry Van Dyke was a great talent and the Dick Van Dyke Show is one of television's greatest sitcoms, but the episodes in question sadly ended up among the weaker ones of the 5 season run.
And 'Long Night’s Journey Into Day' is a top 10 episode for me. Definitely not 83rd best for me.
"NOBODY knows how I feel!"
I just watched the "nobody knows how I feel" episode a few nights ago.
Always been disappointed that his episodes hadn't turned out better. I think they perhaps even realized it at the time that they were somewhat weak, since this particular episode was left wide open for a follow-up episode involving his marriage with Julie. Yet that was the end of it all and we never hear from Stacey Petrie again after that two part season 4 episode.
And the sleepwalking one that introduced Rob's brother to us a season or two earlier should've been one of the all-time great sitcom episodes. A Dick Van Dyke Show episode that involves sleepwalking sounds like a match made in heaven for a great sitcom like this. But the end result ended up merely okay rather than a classic.
His four appearances definitely were a missed opportunity. Jerry Van Dyke was a great talent and the Dick Van Dyke Show is one of television's greatest sitcoms, but the episodes in question sadly ended up among the weaker ones of the 5 season run.
Last edited: