Ted Todorov
Senior HTF Member
- Joined
- Aug 17, 2000
- Messages
- 3,709
I just got a chance to watch the new DVD of Ernst Lubitsch's 1940 film The Shop Around The Corner and couldn't recommend it more highly.
The film is absolutely great. Scintillating dialog, great acting, wonderful characters, great humor, romance, it's all there! This definitely falls into the "they don't make them like this any more" category. One just needs to watch the relatively lame You've Got Mail remake to get that point. It is hard to single out any of the performances as they are uniformly great, but in the staring role Jimmy Stewart is just perfect, keeping his mannerisms in check, and absolutely inhabiting his character. William Tracy steals numerous scenes as Pepi, the stock boy, including the absolutely priceless one where he puts a pompous psychiatrist in his place. The dialog in general has so much more bite than anything on view these days.
The DVD itself is outstanding -- the picture is absolutely outstanding considering the age of the film. Apart from some judder during the opening credits, I couldn't see a single problem.
The sound is just about perfect as well. Often it seems that it is easier to fix the picture of an old film than the sound (I've noticed this problem on a number of Criterion DVDs of '30s & '40s films). Not with The Shop Around The Corner where all the dialog comes across with perfect intelligibility and the music and all else sounds great.
The only real extra was a sound film promo which I didn't watch. Yes, there is a trailer, though why people care about trailers when they have just seen the movie I'll never know.
For anyone out there who loves movies, this is a must buy DVD -- great film, great DVD, watching it is pure pleasure.
Ted
The film is absolutely great. Scintillating dialog, great acting, wonderful characters, great humor, romance, it's all there! This definitely falls into the "they don't make them like this any more" category. One just needs to watch the relatively lame You've Got Mail remake to get that point. It is hard to single out any of the performances as they are uniformly great, but in the staring role Jimmy Stewart is just perfect, keeping his mannerisms in check, and absolutely inhabiting his character. William Tracy steals numerous scenes as Pepi, the stock boy, including the absolutely priceless one where he puts a pompous psychiatrist in his place. The dialog in general has so much more bite than anything on view these days.
The DVD itself is outstanding -- the picture is absolutely outstanding considering the age of the film. Apart from some judder during the opening credits, I couldn't see a single problem.
The sound is just about perfect as well. Often it seems that it is easier to fix the picture of an old film than the sound (I've noticed this problem on a number of Criterion DVDs of '30s & '40s films). Not with The Shop Around The Corner where all the dialog comes across with perfect intelligibility and the music and all else sounds great.
The only real extra was a sound film promo which I didn't watch. Yes, there is a trailer, though why people care about trailers when they have just seen the movie I'll never know.
For anyone out there who loves movies, this is a must buy DVD -- great film, great DVD, watching it is pure pleasure.
Ted