Matt_Stevens
Supporting Actor
- Joined
- Dec 3, 2000
- Messages
- 747
The comments in this review are my opinion. Opinions are subjective. So read on and enjoy.
Got it in last night and watched the documentary and half the film. Packaging for the LE is very heavy and unfortunately, one of the brackets holding the booklet & lobby cards in place was broken (any way to fix that?). I moved the CD to the front and the DVD to the back, that way I can open the back part of the case and not the front.
The booklet is interesting and has an informative interview with the film's star, Jessica Harper. The lobby cards are cool, but I think some what a waste. I'd rather not have them and the price be $5 lower, but at $29 shipped, I cannot complain.
The 2nd disc has a 52 minute documentary and it was shot in 1.85:1 anamorphic, with the scenes from the film in 2.35:1 anamorphic. Having the interviews 1.85:1 is a God-send for owners of 16x9 sets, like myself. This is a fascinating making of with interviews of the cast and crew and fans of the film will not want to miss it. The section on the 3 strip TECHNICOLOR format is of great interest to film buffs and tech heads.
What's even more interesting is that both Daria Nicolodi and Dario Argento claim to have come up with the story for SUSPIRIA. I tend to think Daria came up with the story and Dario enhanced it. It's clear from the interviews here and in OPERA that the two lovers did not exactly split on the best of terms. It's amazing Daria appeared in PHENOMENON and OPERA, which were filmed after their breakup. Her comments in the film bio about her scream at the end of TENEBRAE are quite funny. I wonder if Dario had her dubbed by Theresa Russell for spite???
The other extras include the U.S. and international trailer in anamorphic 1.85:1, as well as a TV commercial. There is a nasty looking shot on video music video that I stopped watching after 20 seconds because I found it to be utterly boring.
The menu designs are thankfully quick, with the Goblin music used throughout.
There is no commentary, thank the Lord, as Argento commentaries are a laborious exercise in frustration (I talked with Cary Roan about that a few years ago).
Having watched about 1 hour+ of the film (in one sitting), I can safely say that this transfer is an absolute triumph. There is none of the dot crawl, chroma noise or image distortions of the Magnum laserdisc release (one of my favorites). The 3 strip technicolor images are detailed, vibrant and beautiful. On my 47" Panasonic HDTV, the image is among the best I have ever seen and would lead people to believe that this film was shot last year and not 25 years ago. Anchor Bay's DEEP RED transfer is similar in appearance and quality.
Compression artifacts are here, but only fleetingly. The color red seems to be tough for MPEG2, but thanfully Anchor By was able to recreate that vibrant color without pixalization. Only a few scenes show the annoying pixel problem, sometimes in the fade to blacks. You won't notice this on a direct view TV (36" tube & under).
The soundtrack is a mixed back. Owners of the laserdisc know that SUSPIRIA's PCM track is among the very best ever created. It's powerful and scary with wonderful directional dialogue and an aggressive surround presence. The new 6.1 and DTS remixes are no less impressive, but not much of an improvement (I listened to them in 5.1). The split rears sure as hell work, but the front sound stage didn't pack the extra punch I thought it would (especially during the opening sequence). Some sounds, like Sarah's screams in the barbed wire, are muted in comparison to the laserdisc's PCM track (in favor of pumping up the music). And unfortunately, the 2.0 surround track on the DVD is not the original. It is a downmix from the 5.1. I compared them and I have no doubt of this.
Still, those of you looking for an aggressive surround track need not be upset. SUSPIRIA fits that description and I am pleased with it. The difference between the DD5.1 and the DTS is slight, mostly in the rears. I do not have a 6.1 setup, so I cannot comment on the EX nature of the soundtracks.
Those of you worried about the film being cut, relax. After comparing one scene from the laserdisc to the same scene on the DVD, it appears that this DVD is fully uncut. I have not had a chance to compare the film's last few murder sequences, but I don't think I have to.
During tonight's HTF chat I plan on thanking Anchor Bay for the enormous effort it took for them to acquire and release this classic horror film on DVD, as well as the other Argentos. I do hope they revisit TENEBRAE next year, as it's 4:3 1.85:1 transfer is severely lacking in comparison to the 16x9 transfers of the other Argento films, all of which were restored from the original elements.
thumps up.
------------------
www.deceptions.net/superman
P.S. I had a hell of a time posting this. Spell check wouldn't work, etc. So if there any spelling errors, please forgive me.
[Edited last by Matt_Stevens on September 18, 2001 at 01:39 PM]
Got it in last night and watched the documentary and half the film. Packaging for the LE is very heavy and unfortunately, one of the brackets holding the booklet & lobby cards in place was broken (any way to fix that?). I moved the CD to the front and the DVD to the back, that way I can open the back part of the case and not the front.
The booklet is interesting and has an informative interview with the film's star, Jessica Harper. The lobby cards are cool, but I think some what a waste. I'd rather not have them and the price be $5 lower, but at $29 shipped, I cannot complain.
The 2nd disc has a 52 minute documentary and it was shot in 1.85:1 anamorphic, with the scenes from the film in 2.35:1 anamorphic. Having the interviews 1.85:1 is a God-send for owners of 16x9 sets, like myself. This is a fascinating making of with interviews of the cast and crew and fans of the film will not want to miss it. The section on the 3 strip TECHNICOLOR format is of great interest to film buffs and tech heads.
What's even more interesting is that both Daria Nicolodi and Dario Argento claim to have come up with the story for SUSPIRIA. I tend to think Daria came up with the story and Dario enhanced it. It's clear from the interviews here and in OPERA that the two lovers did not exactly split on the best of terms. It's amazing Daria appeared in PHENOMENON and OPERA, which were filmed after their breakup. Her comments in the film bio about her scream at the end of TENEBRAE are quite funny. I wonder if Dario had her dubbed by Theresa Russell for spite???
The other extras include the U.S. and international trailer in anamorphic 1.85:1, as well as a TV commercial. There is a nasty looking shot on video music video that I stopped watching after 20 seconds because I found it to be utterly boring.
The menu designs are thankfully quick, with the Goblin music used throughout.
There is no commentary, thank the Lord, as Argento commentaries are a laborious exercise in frustration (I talked with Cary Roan about that a few years ago).
Having watched about 1 hour+ of the film (in one sitting), I can safely say that this transfer is an absolute triumph. There is none of the dot crawl, chroma noise or image distortions of the Magnum laserdisc release (one of my favorites). The 3 strip technicolor images are detailed, vibrant and beautiful. On my 47" Panasonic HDTV, the image is among the best I have ever seen and would lead people to believe that this film was shot last year and not 25 years ago. Anchor Bay's DEEP RED transfer is similar in appearance and quality.
Compression artifacts are here, but only fleetingly. The color red seems to be tough for MPEG2, but thanfully Anchor By was able to recreate that vibrant color without pixalization. Only a few scenes show the annoying pixel problem, sometimes in the fade to blacks. You won't notice this on a direct view TV (36" tube & under).
The soundtrack is a mixed back. Owners of the laserdisc know that SUSPIRIA's PCM track is among the very best ever created. It's powerful and scary with wonderful directional dialogue and an aggressive surround presence. The new 6.1 and DTS remixes are no less impressive, but not much of an improvement (I listened to them in 5.1). The split rears sure as hell work, but the front sound stage didn't pack the extra punch I thought it would (especially during the opening sequence). Some sounds, like Sarah's screams in the barbed wire, are muted in comparison to the laserdisc's PCM track (in favor of pumping up the music). And unfortunately, the 2.0 surround track on the DVD is not the original. It is a downmix from the 5.1. I compared them and I have no doubt of this.
Still, those of you looking for an aggressive surround track need not be upset. SUSPIRIA fits that description and I am pleased with it. The difference between the DD5.1 and the DTS is slight, mostly in the rears. I do not have a 6.1 setup, so I cannot comment on the EX nature of the soundtracks.
Those of you worried about the film being cut, relax. After comparing one scene from the laserdisc to the same scene on the DVD, it appears that this DVD is fully uncut. I have not had a chance to compare the film's last few murder sequences, but I don't think I have to.
During tonight's HTF chat I plan on thanking Anchor Bay for the enormous effort it took for them to acquire and release this classic horror film on DVD, as well as the other Argentos. I do hope they revisit TENEBRAE next year, as it's 4:3 1.85:1 transfer is severely lacking in comparison to the 16x9 transfers of the other Argento films, all of which were restored from the original elements.
------------------
www.deceptions.net/superman
P.S. I had a hell of a time posting this. Spell check wouldn't work, etc. So if there any spelling errors, please forgive me.
[Edited last by Matt_Stevens on September 18, 2001 at 01:39 PM]