Donnie Eldridge
Supporting Actor
- Joined
- Jan 3, 2001
- Messages
- 761
Are there any early reviews out yet? I'm debating whether to wait or pick up the HK 2-disc set.
The Criterion disc mentions optional director's commentary on the deleted scenes. This might be an exclusive Criterion extra, and in my opinion quite a significant one.
This is on the French disc. The short film is not. The extras on the French DVD run to 2 hours and there is little that is "filler". Also, if Criterion hold true to form, the transfer will be improperly framed at 1.85:1, where the French and UK DVDs were properly framed at 1.66:1. It's an annoying and avoidable habit which hurt their otherwise excellent DVDs of Discrete Charm and Ruling Class (among others) which turns me away from the Criterion DVD.
I have to throw in that the reason how I can tell myself that a purchase is NECESSARY, is the fact that this Criterion release will have an ALL NEW digital transfer - how about that
How many "all new digital transfers" does a 2 year old film need? The French/UK DVD also has an "all new digital transfer".
Also, if Criterion hold true to form, the transfer will be improperly framed at 1.85:1, where the French and UK DVDs were properly framed at 1.66:1.
That's a little harsh - it's very rare for Criterion to get the the aspect ratio wrong. And the web site specifically states 1.66:1. I know, they probably claimed this for Discreet Charm as well, but I'm confident they won't screw it up.
1. Criterion's ITMFL does include an exclusive transfer.
2. We are releasing ITMFL as 5.0 because the DA-88 master we received
from Europe had no audio information on the LFE track (the .1 track).
3. The Wong Kar-Wai World Tour is actually the last four minutes of a
longer piece called @ In The Mood For Love. The entirety of this
documentary appears on the Criterion release (I think it's about 50
minutes). The Cannes Film Masterclass also appears on the Criterion
release. However, it is not multi-angle on our version.
This certainly clears some things up, and to me the Criterion is now the way to go.