Juan C Toro
Stunt Coordinator
- Joined
- Jul 23, 2001
- Messages
- 119
Just bear with me for a second with the background of my story, and I will get to the main issue, so I can benefit from all your expertise:
Recently, my DVD player, a Toshiba SD-2700 died on me, and became an overpriced CD Player: Doesn't play DVDs, only CDs. So in the meantime, I was watching DVDs in my backup player, an APEX that is attached to a second TV in the children's room.
Finally, after Christmas, I went to buy a new DVD Player, and chose the SONY DVP-NS715P, with Progressive Scanning. And although it was supposed to be the end of my shopping, I ended up leaving the store with my player and a Samsung Widescreen TV, the HCM4216W, 1080i HDTV capable (talking about impulsive buying), to replace my old 21 inches TV. It was delivered a week later, and I love it. I am feeding the video using component video cable, and my DVDs look great, and sound great as well with my basic and very reliable Kenwood VR-407 receiver, Dolby Digital and DTS capable, with 100 watts output per channel.
When setting up the DVD for Progressive scanning signal, I do not have the possibility of using the TV's various setting for the viewing format (Normal 4:3, Wide, Panorama, DVD and Zoom), so if the image is in any ratio lower than 16x9, it will be stretched horizontally.
Which brings me to the subject matter: I got Lilo & Stitch, and watched the movie, and later I realized the aspect ratio is 1.66:1, so it was stretched (although it looked fine to me, maybe it was the style of the character design). So I changed the setting of the player from Progressive to Interlaced, and now the movie is in its proper ratio (I assume), but I have those "ugly gray bars" on the side.
What do you think is the proper way to watch movies in this ratio? And second, why do they still make movies in this ration, when in a couple of years, when widescreen TV are more common, the movie will look "dated", since it will not conform to the standard 16x9 ratio?
And also, while I am at it... In movies with aspect ratios wider than 1.85:1, Shouldn't the bars at the top and bottom display in gray rather than black, to avoid the risk of screen "burn in".
JC
Recently, my DVD player, a Toshiba SD-2700 died on me, and became an overpriced CD Player: Doesn't play DVDs, only CDs. So in the meantime, I was watching DVDs in my backup player, an APEX that is attached to a second TV in the children's room.
Finally, after Christmas, I went to buy a new DVD Player, and chose the SONY DVP-NS715P, with Progressive Scanning. And although it was supposed to be the end of my shopping, I ended up leaving the store with my player and a Samsung Widescreen TV, the HCM4216W, 1080i HDTV capable (talking about impulsive buying), to replace my old 21 inches TV. It was delivered a week later, and I love it. I am feeding the video using component video cable, and my DVDs look great, and sound great as well with my basic and very reliable Kenwood VR-407 receiver, Dolby Digital and DTS capable, with 100 watts output per channel.
When setting up the DVD for Progressive scanning signal, I do not have the possibility of using the TV's various setting for the viewing format (Normal 4:3, Wide, Panorama, DVD and Zoom), so if the image is in any ratio lower than 16x9, it will be stretched horizontally.
Which brings me to the subject matter: I got Lilo & Stitch, and watched the movie, and later I realized the aspect ratio is 1.66:1, so it was stretched (although it looked fine to me, maybe it was the style of the character design). So I changed the setting of the player from Progressive to Interlaced, and now the movie is in its proper ratio (I assume), but I have those "ugly gray bars" on the side.
What do you think is the proper way to watch movies in this ratio? And second, why do they still make movies in this ration, when in a couple of years, when widescreen TV are more common, the movie will look "dated", since it will not conform to the standard 16x9 ratio?
And also, while I am at it... In movies with aspect ratios wider than 1.85:1, Shouldn't the bars at the top and bottom display in gray rather than black, to avoid the risk of screen "burn in".
JC