Ok - first my standard disclaimer; im definately not an audiophile. however, i can tell the difference between good and bad speakers. as a reference and a little background, i lived in a townhouse before i was married last year where my best friend and i had a pretty nice setup. we had a Marantz sr 7300 preamping a rotel 1075 amp playing through a 5 piece B&W setup: 604s for mains, 601s for rears, an LCR 600 center, and an SVS 20-39 sub.
but i digress; back to the audition: as i took the Marantz with me when i moved into a new town home with my wife, i was looking for speakers that would match it as well as my budget of no more than $1000 for all 5 speakers. i was originally looking at JBLs Northridge series but my friend talked me into not looking at them. so i had narrowed it down to the Mordaunt Short Avant line as i was determined to have the maple finish. my friend recommended Paradigm as the best speaker for the buck at that price point. to apease him (i had already made my mind up, just not auditioned) i included a stop at a dealer carrying that line when i went to audition the MS line.
Mordaunt short 914s: construction wise, these speakers were a work of art. the veneer really looked like wood to me. the materials were of high quality with the terminals gold plated and biampable/biwirable. i liked the fact you could fill the cabinets with sand and loved how they looked with the grills off (a must for my preferences)
they handled the demo disk i created with ease. both a mixture of rock and slower, van morrison style music emphasising vocals. pros: the midrange is what these speakers are all about! they are some of the most accurate speakers i have ever heard with an astounding clarity. not necessarily a detriment, these speakers were very laid back; almost like energy speakers.
as far as cons go, the only thing i can say is they were a little too laid back for my taste. i need a more robust, fuller (less refined maybe) speaker. other than that, nothing. the best prices i found were online at "wild west electronics"
Paradigm Phantoms: from the first time i saw them, i knew i wanted the Mordaunts. i just didn't like the black finish. i thought it looked too 'plasticky'. still, i liked that for the same money, i got an extra driver and proceeded to audition them.
from the first 10 seconds of listening to them, i had to admit they had the Mordaunts beat. the highs were crisper and more articulated than the MSs and the lower registers were not missing as in the 914s. the extra driver gave the phantoms a fuller sound, leaving the 914s sounding sort of thin. in stereo mode the 914s just didn't do well enough.
as with anything, there is a trade off. the phantoms were not biwirable and there was a lack of 'expensivity' to the build quality.
Conclusions: well, as much as i loved the way the 914s looked and disliked the way the phantoms looked...i loved the way the Paradigms sounded more. they were just more of a forward sounding speaker that suits my music tastes of mainly rock better. Paradigm clearly spent most of their money on the way their performance line sounds and the rest on building them. while Mordaunt Short would be a perfect speaker for declaring that you have an expensive home theater setup, Paradigm wins in a blind A-B audition.
However, i definately want to defend the Mordaunts (they were that good) by saying that with a sub in the equation, the lack of bottom end would not be a problem. if my wife had not have thought the black would match our living room better than the maple of the 914s, i would have bought the Mordaunt Avant line instead of Paradigm's Performance.
i purchased the Atoms as surrounds but have listened to them as a bookshelf system and they are simply amazing! you would not be amiss to get four of these and a sub for a budget theater setup: they really shine
but i digress; back to the audition: as i took the Marantz with me when i moved into a new town home with my wife, i was looking for speakers that would match it as well as my budget of no more than $1000 for all 5 speakers. i was originally looking at JBLs Northridge series but my friend talked me into not looking at them. so i had narrowed it down to the Mordaunt Short Avant line as i was determined to have the maple finish. my friend recommended Paradigm as the best speaker for the buck at that price point. to apease him (i had already made my mind up, just not auditioned) i included a stop at a dealer carrying that line when i went to audition the MS line.
Mordaunt short 914s: construction wise, these speakers were a work of art. the veneer really looked like wood to me. the materials were of high quality with the terminals gold plated and biampable/biwirable. i liked the fact you could fill the cabinets with sand and loved how they looked with the grills off (a must for my preferences)
they handled the demo disk i created with ease. both a mixture of rock and slower, van morrison style music emphasising vocals. pros: the midrange is what these speakers are all about! they are some of the most accurate speakers i have ever heard with an astounding clarity. not necessarily a detriment, these speakers were very laid back; almost like energy speakers.
as far as cons go, the only thing i can say is they were a little too laid back for my taste. i need a more robust, fuller (less refined maybe) speaker. other than that, nothing. the best prices i found were online at "wild west electronics"
Paradigm Phantoms: from the first time i saw them, i knew i wanted the Mordaunts. i just didn't like the black finish. i thought it looked too 'plasticky'. still, i liked that for the same money, i got an extra driver and proceeded to audition them.
from the first 10 seconds of listening to them, i had to admit they had the Mordaunts beat. the highs were crisper and more articulated than the MSs and the lower registers were not missing as in the 914s. the extra driver gave the phantoms a fuller sound, leaving the 914s sounding sort of thin. in stereo mode the 914s just didn't do well enough.
as with anything, there is a trade off. the phantoms were not biwirable and there was a lack of 'expensivity' to the build quality.
Conclusions: well, as much as i loved the way the 914s looked and disliked the way the phantoms looked...i loved the way the Paradigms sounded more. they were just more of a forward sounding speaker that suits my music tastes of mainly rock better. Paradigm clearly spent most of their money on the way their performance line sounds and the rest on building them. while Mordaunt Short would be a perfect speaker for declaring that you have an expensive home theater setup, Paradigm wins in a blind A-B audition.
However, i definately want to defend the Mordaunts (they were that good) by saying that with a sub in the equation, the lack of bottom end would not be a problem. if my wife had not have thought the black would match our living room better than the maple of the 914s, i would have bought the Mordaunt Avant line instead of Paradigm's Performance.
i purchased the Atoms as surrounds but have listened to them as a bookshelf system and they are simply amazing! you would not be amiss to get four of these and a sub for a budget theater setup: they really shine