"Do you want to watch the Theatrical or [Insert: Unrated/Extended/Director's Cut]?" is a question most us have encountered when playing a Blu-ray or a DVD. Or even when you're about to stream a movie.
Nowadays, with numerous different editions of many films, it can be hard to determine which edition to watch. Is it the “unrated cut” or the “director’s cut” or even the “extended cut”? Studios and their marketing departments can slap “special edition” on any disc but that’s no guarantee for a special treatment. Even the wide used “director’s cut” can, and has been, used in marketing purposes with no approval from the director.
I'll get to the point: I got frustrated with the many cuts of movies that I can choose from, because I just want to watch the movie that the director wants me to see. So I began to compile information about various editions by listening to commentaries, reading books, working through interviews, and by asking the director what is their preferred version. And with all that information I started a site called This or That Edition.
Some movies that This or That Edition has covered: Alien, Aliens, Gladiator, The Iron Giant, Mad Max: Fury Road, Payback, Straight Outta Compton, Terminator 2: Judgement Day and The Wolverine.
More than a year later I have 161 entries on the site with personal confirmation from directors like Judd Apatow, Paul Feig, Ben Stiller, James Mangold, Joe Carnahan, Greg Mottola, Joe Johnston, Francis Lawrence, Brett Ratner, Josh Boone, Paul Haggis, Etan Cohen, Nicholas Stroller and Richard Kelly.
I hope that you fellow cinephiles can enjoy the site.
Nowadays, with numerous different editions of many films, it can be hard to determine which edition to watch. Is it the “unrated cut” or the “director’s cut” or even the “extended cut”? Studios and their marketing departments can slap “special edition” on any disc but that’s no guarantee for a special treatment. Even the wide used “director’s cut” can, and has been, used in marketing purposes with no approval from the director.
I'll get to the point: I got frustrated with the many cuts of movies that I can choose from, because I just want to watch the movie that the director wants me to see. So I began to compile information about various editions by listening to commentaries, reading books, working through interviews, and by asking the director what is their preferred version. And with all that information I started a site called This or That Edition.
Some movies that This or That Edition has covered: Alien, Aliens, Gladiator, The Iron Giant, Mad Max: Fury Road, Payback, Straight Outta Compton, Terminator 2: Judgement Day and The Wolverine.
More than a year later I have 161 entries on the site with personal confirmation from directors like Judd Apatow, Paul Feig, Ben Stiller, James Mangold, Joe Carnahan, Greg Mottola, Joe Johnston, Francis Lawrence, Brett Ratner, Josh Boone, Paul Haggis, Etan Cohen, Nicholas Stroller and Richard Kelly.
I hope that you fellow cinephiles can enjoy the site.