What's new

Blu-ray Review White Zombie Blu-ray Review (1 Viewer)

Todd Erwin

Reviewer
HW Reviewer
Senior HTF Member
Joined
Apr 16, 2008
Messages
10,450
Location
Hawthorne, NV
Real Name
Todd Erwin
One of the first films to launch the zombie sub-genre of horror films, Victor Halperin’s White Zombie had been public domain fodder on VHS and DVD for decades, using prints that were several generations removed from the camera negative. Holland Releasing has licensed their recent restoration from 35mm and 16mm elements to Kino Classics, with mixed results.

White Zombie Studio: Kino Classics US BD Release Date: January 29, 2013 Original Release Year: 1932 Rated: Not Rated Running Time: 69 minutes Aspect Ratio: 1.33:1 (pillar-boxed) Audio: English (PCM 2.0 Mono) Subtitles: None Movie: 3 out of 5 After the success of Dracula in 1931 for Universal, Bela Lugosi appeared in White Zombie, a low budget horror film produced by the Halperin Brothers, as Murder Legendre, a voodoo master in charge of running the sugar mill for Haitian plantation owner Charles Beaumont (Robert Frazer). When Madeline (Madge Bellamy) arrives in Haiti to be married to her fiance Neil Parker (John Harron), Beaumont invites the couple to have the ceremony performed at his mansion. But both Beaumont and Legendre are infatuated with Madeline, and during the reception, Legendre transforms her into a zombie at Beaumont’s request. Neil turns to missionary Dr. Bruner (Joseph Cawthorn), who performed the wedding ceremony, to find a way to save Madeline from her tragic fate. While not a great film by any means, White Zombie is one of the better films Lugosi appeared in following the hugely successful Dracula, before he would eventually become typecast in roles that would often parody his star-making role. Lugosi is one of the few good performances in a film featuring many silent stars who never quite made the transition to talkies. Madge Bellamy’s performance as Madeline is so stiff that it is hard to distinguish if her character was a zombie before the transformation. Robert Frazer plays Baeumont with the overacting that may have been acceptable in the silent era, but comes across as too much, even in the early days of sound. And Joseph Cawthorn, who is given the responsibility of comic relief with his running matchstick gag, overstays his welcome very fast. Where the film excels is in its production design and use of early optical effects. As a way of saving money, the Halperin’s leased many of the same sets and props Universal used on Dracula and Frankenstein (they even shot much of the film on the Universal lot), giving the film a much higher production value. White Zombie also made interesting use of split screens and wipes, as well as double exposures and matte paintings. Video: 2 out of 5 Kino’s new Blu-ray (and DVD) offer the viewer two versions of White Zombie to watch. Selecting Play Film from the Main Menu takes you to the recent restoration financed by Holland Releasing and completed using AlgoSoft’s automated VIVA software after a 2k harvest from a 35mm collector’s print (as well as a 16mm print for missing footage), which automatically detects and corrects and/or removes dirt, flicker, imperfections, brightness, grain, noise, and other defects. What the software ultimately proves is that restoration of a film is an art form, not something that can be easily accomplished by simply loading a computer program and hitting “run.” The 1080p transfer, compressed using the AVC codec, retains the original aspect ratio of 1.33:1, but brightness and contrast are completely blown out, grain has been almost completely obliterated, and the software has difficulty keeping up with many of the changes in light levels, resulting in very noticeable banding. Edge enhancement has also been overused, causing extreme halos around light sources, such as candles. On the completely other end of the spectrum, Kino has included what they refer to as a “raw, unenhanced” transfer that can be found in the Extras section of the disc. The “raw” version looks only slightly better than the poor transfers we’ve been seeing of this title on public domain DVDs and VHS tapes for several years. The image is overly dark, with intense grain buildup likely from being several generations removed from the original negative. In the proper hands, the restored version should have been somewhere between the two versions provided on this disc. Audio: 3 out of 5 For the audio portion of the restoration, Holland Releasing turned to Chace Audio by Deluxe to clean up the existing soundtrack. I’m happy to report that Chace did as good a job as could possibly be done, considering the source material they had to work with. The PCM 2.0 mono soundtrack on the restored version has a much cleaner sound, with pops, crackles, hiss, surface noise, and dropouts less noticeable than the raw version. Special Features: 3 out of 5 All of the special features are in high definition. White Zombie (RAW) (67:16): Running approximately one minute shorter (due to the addition of logos and restoration credits to the restored version), Kino presents the film in an unaltered form, free of any digital enhancements (see the video section above). Audio Commentary by Film Historian Frank Thompson: Thompson provides some interesting history behind the film and its producers, as well as some of the untrue myths told by the film’s stars. Unfortunately, Thompson does praise the restoration work performed on the film. Intimate Interviews: Bela Lugosi (6:51): Dorothy West interviews Lugosi at his home in this vintage short produced by Talking Picture Epics. Theatrical Trailer (2:47): This is the 1951 re-release trailer. Still Gallery: A series of 16 lobby cards and posters from the film’s press kit. Overall: 2.5 out of 5 Although it is nice to see a company willing to finance the restoration of a film that has fallen into the public domain, it is a shame that the money could have been spent on a better, hand-crafted restoration than this botched, automated effort. Kudos to Kino for including an unadulterated version, but it just proves that you can’t turn everything over to a computer and press the start button.

 

bgart13

Screenwriter
Joined
Oct 4, 2008
Messages
1,112
Real Name
Ben
Algosoft has taken exception with the final product too, btw. http://thelatarniaforums.yuku.com/reply/155420/Kinos-WHITE-ZOMBIE-1932-bluray#reply-155420 They state that Crawford did further work which they feel negatively affected the work that Algosoft had done.
 

Ruz-El

Fake Shemp
Senior HTF Member
Joined
Sep 20, 2002
Messages
12,540
Location
Deadmonton
Real Name
Russell
Interesting that even the people involved don;t like it. Weird that Kino released this at all. I'll skip it unless it hits insane $5 bin price levels.
 

JoHud

Senior HTF Member
Joined
Sep 12, 2007
Messages
3,215
Real Name
Joe Hudak
There was another company responsible for this release called Holland Releasing that had a defensive stance regarding the negative criticism during a recent interview. Well, less defensive and more like dodging responsibility.
Of course, any restoration invites an amount of controversy, and WHITE ZOMBIE is no exception to this rule. The Holland restoration, which has been licensed for use on an upcoming DVD and Blu-Ray release by Kino/Fox Lorber, is already attracting its share of debate from advance reviews. (The release offers two viewing options for comparison: the Holland restoration and a “raw” transfer of the print used prior to AlgoSoft’s restorative work.) However, without actually being able to see an arc light-projected silver nitrate print of WHITE ZOMBIE, it’s impossible to say that the Holland restoration is an inaccurate representation of how the film looked in 1932.
 

bigshot

Senior HTF Member
Joined
Jan 30, 2008
Messages
2,933
Real Name
Stephen
I thought the restored version was completely watchable, which is more than I can say about any ofthe previous DVD releases. This film was badly processed in the beginning. The optical wipes and dissolves are horribly handled and no amount of restoration would fix that. On top of that, the film was neglected and duped many times. What we've got is what we've got. It's not liable to look better.
 

warnerbro

Supporting Actor
Joined
Jun 22, 2010
Messages
971
Location
Burbank, California
Real Name
Darrell
I was happy with this release. I think this is probably as good as it's going to look considering the source material. I like that they give you a choice to see it raw or cleaned up. And yes, the cleaned-up version has been too cleaned up and it looks smeared. But, this looks 100 percent better than anything else we've ever seen and some of the dialogue that was missing before is now back in. There is an excellent commentary. I was blown away by the old interview they included with Bela Lugosi. It's one I've seen before where a blonde journalist interviews Bela Lugosi at home soon after DRACULA. They have restored it in HD and it looks amazing. I think it is worth the price alone.
 

Essanay Paul

Stunt Coordinator
Joined
Dec 8, 2011
Messages
113
Real Name
Paul
Cary Roan (formerly of The Roan Group) is going to release his 35mm version on Blu-ray from VCI Home Video in 2014.

Here is the information I got from VCI about Cary Roan's transfer:
Roan has done a new 4k HD transfer of his materials, plus I believe he has found some new materials to improve some of the scenes. I have seen his rough transfer, before any restoration, and it should produce a very nice Blu-ray. Roan guaranteed me it would blow the Kino version away. We are supposed to get the completed master any day. He is also going to provide a new commentary track by Gary Don Rhodes (wrote book on White Zombie), plus all of the other extras from the laser disc and DVD.

VCI Home Video
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Sign up for our newsletter

and receive essential news, curated deals, and much more







You will only receive emails from us. We will never sell or distribute your email address to third party companies at any time.

Latest Articles

Forum statistics

Threads
357,070
Messages
5,130,053
Members
144,283
Latest member
Nielmb
Recent bookmarks
0
Top