I haven't played Red Dead Revolver but it looks terrible compared to Red Dead Redemption. Redemption is one of my all time faves with one of the best story moments I've played in any game. It's also at this point the only rockstar game that I've manged to finish. Not due to being easy, but due to being such fun to play. I mean, I did all the story stuff, there's all sorts of thing to do to collect trophies which I've not done. The "Undead Nightmare" DLC was ridiculously good too and one of the best zombie games I've played.