What's new

HTF MINI REVIEW: "Silly Symphonies" (1 Viewer)

Ronald Epstein

Founder
Owner
Moderator
Senior HTF Member
Joined
Jul 3, 1997
Messages
66,789
Real Name
Ronald Epstein
21071.jpg


Silly Symphonies

I have to applaud Disney. If you took a look
at their Walt Disney Treasures collection
and had known their home video history these past
10 years, you would be shaking your head in total
disbelief.
We used to constantly mock Disney for their lack
of interest in the Home Video format during both
the laserdisc era and the early DVD era. Trying to
get them to release their most prized product to the
formats became a hopeless cause.
But over the past year or more, changes took place
with management at the studio. Somebody over there
smelled the coffee and realized the significance
of this format and the need to get material released
to the format. This change of attitude at Disney
towards DVD has significantly skyrocketed business
for the studio.
Take these tins, for instance, that were released
at the very end of last year. Mickey Mouse:
In Living Color and Silly Symphonies.
For those of us that knew Disney Home Video, this
is a true earth-moving event for the studio
to release this sort of material.
I bought Mickey Mouse: In Living Color and
have not had the opportunity to even look at its
contents yet. I will admit that I staunchly hesitated
to hold off on buying Silly Symphonies,
because I felt that these would ultimately be
cornball cartoons.
Well, a friend of mine urged me to buy this set.
He told me quite frankly, "You better buy this tin
now as you can't readily find them anymore and these
are cartoons that may never see the light of day again".
In fear that I may miss out on a Collector's prize
that may never be available again, I just ordered
and received the Silly Symphonies 2-disc
collection encased in a numbered tin.
I am calling this a mini-review, because
I have not had the opportunity to watch this entire
collection. After watching a few of the cartoon shorts
this morning, I felt the need to come to the forum
and urge members to buy this set before it is gone.
If nothing else, THIS is animation history.
Silly Symphonies are the very earliest
cartoons produced by Walt Disney starting in 1929
and going through 1939. The premise was simple:
put out fun little cartoons set to original music.
Not only were these cartoons groundbreaking as far
as animation was concerned, but the newly developed
technicolor process also played an essential role
in some of these early shorts. It's interesting
to note that Walt Disney took a huge risk with the
early 3-strip Technicolor technology and ended up
having his short, Flowers and Trees win an
Academy award (1932) as a result.
I watched 4 of the 31 uncensored cartoons presented
in this 2-disc collection. I can't begin to tell
you how impressed I was with these cartoons. After
70 years, these cartoons still seem fresh, displaying
unique personality that hasn't dulled with age.
Three Little Pigs was fun to watch. I
remember seeing this short as a kid, and was thrilled
to watch the pigs playing theit flute and violin
dancing around without cares of the looming wolf.
Skeleton Dance, a black and white short, is
extremely eerie and entertaining. It's amazing to
see how well black and white suits this cartoon.
Flowers and Trees is a uniquely imaginative
tale of singing flowers and trees who are suddenly
disrupted by fire that rages through their forest.
To watch the imaginative minds of the writers and
animators who show flowers washing themselves in
puddles or birds poking holes in clouds for rain,
will bring a smile to your face.
The quality of these shorts look great. Of course
there are blemishes on the source material, but you
can plainly see how carefully these shorts have
been preserved for DVD. The audio sounds very clear.
Many of these shorts have a personal introduction
by film historian, Leonard Maltin who has
great knowledge of the material as these were shorts
that he grew up with and has fond remembrances of.
I urge everyone to buy this tin before it disappears
from shelves forever. It's a pinacle piece of
Disney history that clearly shows why the studio
quickly rose to historical status.
 

Jeff Swindoll

Supporting Actor
Joined
Mar 19, 2000
Messages
505
The DVD Gods must've been smiling upon me because I came across the Silly Symphonies set wandering through Walmart. Looked like the only one they had. I havent had time to give it a spin, but it looks most impressive. Pity that Wallymart didnt have the Mickey Mouse one or I'd have gotten it as well. Looks like the House of Mouse is coming around to DVD with these sets and the nice 2 disc Tron set ;).
I'd disagree a small bit with your comment about LD. Disney produced some of my favourite LDs (methinks they called it the Archives series), 20,000 Leagues under the Sea (when it comes to DVD it better get the Tron treatment ;) ) and the SE LD of Peter Pan. We'll see how much of the LD Peter Pan makes it to the DVD. I recall the LD had a great amount of conceptual drawings and I'm wondering if all of those will make the DVD cut.
 

Colin Jacobson

Senior HTF Member
Joined
Apr 19, 2000
Messages
13,328
We used to constantly mock Disney for their lack

of interest in the Home Video format during both

the laserdisc era and the early DVD era. Trying to

get them to release their most prized product to the

formats became a hopeless cause.
??? Disney offered some of the finest LD boxed sets ever seen. The Lion King, Toy Story, Alice in Wonderland and many others showed the format at its best...
 

Mark_TS

Screenwriter
Joined
Mar 23, 2000
Messages
1,704
Great review, Ron. Luckily I have mine.

As others note, Disney was actually quite good to the LD Collector....many box sets, "Classic" releases and rarely a bare bones offering. I do recall they got kind of pissy when the MICKEY MOUSE B&W Collection failed to sell well-but that was late in the game.

I hope we see 20.000 LEAGUES UNDER THE SEA, soon...
 

Michael St. Clair

Senior HTF Member
Joined
May 3, 1999
Messages
6,001
Disney on LD was fantastic and I don't remember any complaints. I'll never sell my 'Toy Story' box with the lenticular print and the cool booklet and especially the complete (up to that point) set of Pixar shorts!
And you certainly can't have my full bitrate DTS discs like 'Hercules' and 'Hunchback' (not that the new DVDs typically have DTS at all).
We can only hope that they have enough sense to include the Work In Progress version of 'Beauty and the Beast' when they release said film later this year.
 

Kevin Porter

Supporting Actor
Joined
Jan 10, 2002
Messages
948
So do ya'll think this will be a limited production thing? If so, then I need to order mine from deepdiscountdvd.com right away.

~Kevin
 

Douglas R

Senior HTF Member
Joined
Dec 30, 2000
Messages
2,954
Location
London, United Kingdom
Real Name
Doug
Totally agree, Ron. I have the Mickey Mouse and Silly Symphony collections. They are magnificent and form pride of place in my collection. Many years ago I used to buy Disney films on 8mm and it would have cost a fortune to have bought this Disney collection - even if they had been available! These DVDs in comparison, are an absolute bargain.
 

Patrick McCart

Premium
Senior HTF Member
Joined
May 16, 2001
Messages
8,200
Location
Georgia (the state)
Real Name
Patrick McCart
Disney, I think, has learned that UNCENSORED animation sells!

Both the SS and Mickey DVD's are top-notch and are highly entertaining. I would have liked more Mickey cartoons on the MM DVD (It's 2 single layered discs), but I know the Mickey cartoons are hot property. Thanks to these two Walt Disney Treasures cartoon DVD's, Fantasia 2000, and Snow White, I now have 66 Disney cartoons on DVD.

I hope Disney continues this line of limited edition sets with compilations of Donald, Goofy, and B&W Mickey cartoons as well as DVD's with WWII animation and even seasons of Zorro. The other studios with libraries of cartoons..

Warner Bros: Looney Tunes/Merrie Melodies, 1933-1957 Popeye, Tom & Jerry, Tex Avery, the 1941-1943 Superman cartoons, and the pre-1986 MGM cartoons. (One unremarkable Tom & Jerry DVD has been released)

MGM: Pink Panther and some assorted Depatie-Freleng cartoons (One laserdisc re-package of some PP ashorts on DVD.)

Republic: Koko The Clown, Betty Boop, The rest of the Max and Dave Fleischer cartoons (other than the Popeyes), and the 1942-1950 Paramount cartoons.

Paramount: Heckle and Jeckle, Mighty Mouse, and 1962-1967 Paramount cartoons.

Universal: Woody Woodpecker, and other Walter Lantz cartoons

Columbia: Fox & the Crow, Gerald McBoingBoing, Mr. Magoo, other assorted Screen Gems cartoons

Blackhawk Films: ComicColors (Ub Iwerks cartoons), Van Buren cartoons (The 3 Felix the Cat cartoons, for example)

Of these, only Blackhawk has released volumes of cartoons. All the studios need to do what Disney is doing...RELEASING CARTOONS TO DVD!
 

Ronald Epstein

Founder
Owner
Moderator
Senior HTF Member
Joined
Jul 3, 1997
Messages
66,789
Real Name
Ronald Epstein
I need to further clarify my statements

concerning Disney and laserdiscs.

While it is very true that Disney did put out

some incredible laserdisc releases -- those of us

involved in the format from the beginning can clearly

tell you that all this did not come until several

years into the format.

It was a bit of a struggle to urge Disney to put

product out on laserdisc. When they finally started

to, it was a struggle to get them to put out better

product.

By the time Disney was doing justice to the laserdisc

format, DVD was on the horizon.

History repeated itself in 1997 when the studio

withheld from entry into the DVD format and then

when initially entered, lagged behind other studios

in releasing quality product.

Of course, this is now all forgiven history as

Disney is putting out incredible DVD packages and

has done a remarkable contribution to the format's

growth.
 

Richard Smith

Stunt Coordinator
Joined
May 26, 2000
Messages
162
Kevin,

Each of the sets are limited to 150,000 copies. After those are gone thats it. If I was you I'd grab them while you can.

Richard
 

Blu

Screenwriter
Joined
Oct 6, 2001
Messages
1,360
The that because this Tresures series has sold so well we will be seeing more and more Disney on DVD!!!
 

Rob Lutter

Senior HTF Member
Joined
Nov 3, 2000
Messages
4,523
Thanks for the review Ron, I was sorta on the cliff with these releases and your review just toppled me over. I just ordered the Silly Symphonies and Mickey Mouse tins from Amazon.com ...woohoo :D
 

Kenneth Cummings

Supporting Actor
Joined
Aug 7, 2001
Messages
852
Would Amazon still have then in two weeks, because I don't get my allowace until then, and I starting to like ordering from them a bit(finally got our widescreen Wonka from them).
 

Rob Lutter

Senior HTF Member
Joined
Nov 3, 2000
Messages
4,523
Kenneth, I wouldn't count on getting the Mickey Mouse tin 100% in two weeks at Amazon. I usually don't order from them, but both Deep Discount DVD and 800.com are out of stock of the Mickey Mouse tin and I have not seen it at any of the stores around here (just the other tins at Walmart, Costco)
...maybe ask the parents for a payment advance ;)
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Sign up for our newsletter

and receive essential news, curated deals, and much more







You will only receive emails from us. We will never sell or distribute your email address to third party companies at any time.

Forum statistics

Threads
357,063
Messages
5,129,878
Members
144,281
Latest member
papill6n
Recent bookmarks
0
Top