Josh Dial
Senior HTF Member
- Joined
- Jan 2, 2000
- Messages
- 4,513
- Real Name
- Josh Dial
I saw this on opening night.
I really liked it. For the most part I actually loved it.
Florence Pugh is an absolute star. This is established fact. And she's on full display here. Everything she does is compelling and believable. Even the way she sits in the "head of the table' chair during the dinner party scene was perfect.
Pugh and the architecture are the centre pieces of the show, and neither disappoint.
I also quite liked Harry Styles. I think he and Pugh had real on-screen chemistry, even if it was slightly "off" on account of the story itself. He's a bright spot in the last act.
Chris Pine is menacing in a very real way that's never "fun" (which could easily happen in other films--nothing he does here is played for laughs). His body language is so compelling at times. Like Pugh sitting in the chair, just the way Pine comes through the front door at the dinner party scene oozed threat.
Olivia Wilde's performance is also good. And I'm not being dismissive. She's good here. But her directing is excellent. What else do you want from a director (setting aside, of course, the alleged on-set drama)? She got terrific performances out of her cast, found some incredibly gorgeous shots with her cinematographer, Matthew Libatique (who is always stellar), had some interesting framing and camera moves, and set her editor up nicely to cut together a really solid movie. I don't think I found a single moment of obvious ADR. Wilde apparently got all the coverage she needed. Fantastic direction.
On the look and soundscape, it's all beautiful. Maybe the nicest looking movie of the year, besting even Downton Abbey. Everything worked: the costumes, hair, makeup, set, lighting, colour grade, cars, music. You could feel the menace and paranoia, but neither were ever ratcheted up so high as to become overwhelming.
However, as a mystery, I think the final act falls a bit too short of the mark. I don't have a problem with the reveal. I actually liked it and thought it was interesting (though a bit too similar to the great Black Mirror episode "USS Callister").
My problem is that there were a few too many "mysteries" that weren't solved. I don't mean the audience wasn't spoon fed the answers--I have no problem watching something carefully and figuring things out on my own (in fact I prefer it). But there were some things that were never paid off, or if they were I missed them. And I don't think Wilde and the writers are trying to be cute with these things and were "leaving them open to interpretation". I think they just went unexplained, to the movie's detriment.
The things I'm talking about are:
I can't help but think there is a slightly longer cut somewhere with just a few more scenes that address my handful of problems.
8.5/10 for me. Pugh is a 12/10.
I really liked it. For the most part I actually loved it.
Florence Pugh is an absolute star. This is established fact. And she's on full display here. Everything she does is compelling and believable. Even the way she sits in the "head of the table' chair during the dinner party scene was perfect.
Pugh and the architecture are the centre pieces of the show, and neither disappoint.
I also quite liked Harry Styles. I think he and Pugh had real on-screen chemistry, even if it was slightly "off" on account of the story itself. He's a bright spot in the last act.
Chris Pine is menacing in a very real way that's never "fun" (which could easily happen in other films--nothing he does here is played for laughs). His body language is so compelling at times. Like Pugh sitting in the chair, just the way Pine comes through the front door at the dinner party scene oozed threat.
Olivia Wilde's performance is also good. And I'm not being dismissive. She's good here. But her directing is excellent. What else do you want from a director (setting aside, of course, the alleged on-set drama)? She got terrific performances out of her cast, found some incredibly gorgeous shots with her cinematographer, Matthew Libatique (who is always stellar), had some interesting framing and camera moves, and set her editor up nicely to cut together a really solid movie. I don't think I found a single moment of obvious ADR. Wilde apparently got all the coverage she needed. Fantastic direction.
On the look and soundscape, it's all beautiful. Maybe the nicest looking movie of the year, besting even Downton Abbey. Everything worked: the costumes, hair, makeup, set, lighting, colour grade, cars, music. You could feel the menace and paranoia, but neither were ever ratcheted up so high as to become overwhelming.
However, as a mystery, I think the final act falls a bit too short of the mark. I don't have a problem with the reveal. I actually liked it and thought it was interesting (though a bit too similar to the great Black Mirror episode "USS Callister").
My problem is that there were a few too many "mysteries" that weren't solved. I don't mean the audience wasn't spoon fed the answers--I have no problem watching something carefully and figuring things out on my own (in fact I prefer it). But there were some things that were never paid off, or if they were I missed them. And I don't think Wilde and the writers are trying to be cute with these things and were "leaving them open to interpretation". I think they just went unexplained, to the movie's detriment.
The things I'm talking about are:
- The plane. Why did it crash? This is in all the marketing, including at the literal centre of the leaked cover for the steelbook physical media release (which looks beautiful). My best guess is that the neighbour's son was real and he had a toy plane and it worked its way inside someone. Even if I'm close, why is it a centrepiece of the marketing if it's never explained at all?
- The earthquakes. They are shared across all the women, so it can't be localized to them. Why did they happen?
- Shelley's final scene and her final line. I legitimately didn't understand why she said it and the implications. Was it as simple as "now I'm taking over"? If so that's rather boring.
I can't help but think there is a slightly longer cut somewhere with just a few more scenes that address my handful of problems.
8.5/10 for me. Pugh is a 12/10.