- Joined
- Feb 8, 1999
- Messages
- 18,424
- Real Name
- Robert Harris
Like the release of some major motion pictures which hope to capture Academy Award nominations, some of the most important DVDs are arriving as the year comes toward an end.
Just a couple of days after spending some time with King Kong DVD, I've now had an hour or so to sample the seven disc set entitled The Harold Lloyd Comedy Collection.
To have the ability to actually acquire all of these films at the same time is almost beyond belief. New Line has put a great deal of effort into this release, which, like Kong, should go out with a very understandable caveat...
Most films from the silent era no longer exist. So to have these films at all is a joy. These are films which cover the feature length era of Mr. Lloyd's work, with some going back to the teens.
Many of these films are derived from nitrate prints, which were copied to safety stock. Strangely, although the original negatives on many had survived, the odd decision to go from prints seemed to have been made.
Although some of the print materials show wear, there is nothing here of concern, and overall the films are much more than acceptable, some still exhibit the original beauty one might find in a nitrate print.
My personal choice for silent comedy stars has always been Keaton, followed by Lloyd, and then Chaplin.
Silent films, especially for those who have not been exposed to them, seem to pose some sort of cinematic threat. I would advise even those who fear the silent cinema to take a chance on this one.
I should note that the silent films are beautifully scored, and that Mr. Lloyd's work is also represented by "talkies."
In a single package, you're able to access the life's work of one of the world's funniest and most charming comedians.
This is a seven disc cornucopia of some of the finest films ever made, thoroughly and studiously brought to DVD with more bits and extras than one might feel imaginable.
So, for the second time in two days, we have a best of 2005.
In this case, a specialized field... The Lloyd Collection is best silent release of the year, and like Kong, cannot receive a higher recommendation from these quarters.
RAH
Just a couple of days after spending some time with King Kong DVD, I've now had an hour or so to sample the seven disc set entitled The Harold Lloyd Comedy Collection.
To have the ability to actually acquire all of these films at the same time is almost beyond belief. New Line has put a great deal of effort into this release, which, like Kong, should go out with a very understandable caveat...
Most films from the silent era no longer exist. So to have these films at all is a joy. These are films which cover the feature length era of Mr. Lloyd's work, with some going back to the teens.
Many of these films are derived from nitrate prints, which were copied to safety stock. Strangely, although the original negatives on many had survived, the odd decision to go from prints seemed to have been made.
Although some of the print materials show wear, there is nothing here of concern, and overall the films are much more than acceptable, some still exhibit the original beauty one might find in a nitrate print.
My personal choice for silent comedy stars has always been Keaton, followed by Lloyd, and then Chaplin.
Silent films, especially for those who have not been exposed to them, seem to pose some sort of cinematic threat. I would advise even those who fear the silent cinema to take a chance on this one.
I should note that the silent films are beautifully scored, and that Mr. Lloyd's work is also represented by "talkies."
In a single package, you're able to access the life's work of one of the world's funniest and most charming comedians.
This is a seven disc cornucopia of some of the finest films ever made, thoroughly and studiously brought to DVD with more bits and extras than one might feel imaginable.
So, for the second time in two days, we have a best of 2005.
In this case, a specialized field... The Lloyd Collection is best silent release of the year, and like Kong, cannot receive a higher recommendation from these quarters.
RAH