HenryDuBrow
Screenwriter
- Joined
- Jan 23, 2004
- Messages
- 1,517
- Real Name
- Henry.
That scene with Fever and Carlson is great. Such a superb show that deserves the best possible treatment. Incidentally, wonder if Waters or Gilmour are WKRP fans...
HenryDuBrow said:That scene with Fever and Carlson is great. Such a superb show that deserves the best possible treatment. Incidentally, wonder if Waters or Gilmour are WKRP fans...
hey ron,Ron1973 said:Thanks for the explanation, Kevin. As a music fanatic, I've been buying foreign box sets (particularly Bear Family) on American singers forever. I had always heard it was easier/cheaper to license overseas in many cases. I guess that applies to DVD/Blu as well.
hi frank,Frank Soyke said:I just finished watching the show on Antenna TV and I got angry all over again at what has happened with a possible DVD release of it. I hadn't seen it for awhile and I forgot what a great show it is. I remember watching it first run from the pilot on. Pardon the childish sounding diatribe, but I'm way tired of this music rights preventing release crap. I release everything is a business, but things have gotten ridiculous. Felix Unger hums a few bars of a song nobody even remembers and it has to be replaced due to rights problems. Are you freakin kidding me? Further Maude releases are unreleased due to music rights. What? Somebody is overcharging Sony for a tiny handful of songs heard during the entire run. Sunset Strip and Hawaiian Eye are held up cause some moron wants too much money for a bunch of nightclub covers of standards anyone under 70 doesn't even remember. I'm truly tired of it. We classic TV fans pay the price because owners to the rights of obsolete archiaic music are so greedy. That's just flat not right.
Rant complete...
Frank Soyke said:A good example of how ridiculous these rights (music and otherwise) issues have gotten is Adventures In Paradise. Reportedly the Michener estate is asking too much money for the rights. Do these people have such inflated egos that they really think a distributor is going to pay them a gigantic amount of money for a show 95 percent of the public doesn't even remember let alone care about? Other than us, the niche market, who would buy it enough to garner a profit for them? A distributor would be completely stupid to pay an inflated price for a show like that. So instead of charging a reasonable price for the rights and taking the money and run, Micheners heirs want to play hardball and get nothing for the show. Stupidity. End result - We never get a chance to see the show again.
Frank Soyke said:I just finished watching the show on Antenna TV and I got angry all over again at what has happened with a possible DVD release of it. I hadn't seen it for awhile and I forgot what a great show it is. I remember watching it first run from the pilot on. Pardon the childish sounding diatribe, but I'm way tired of this music rights preventing release crap. I release everything is a business, but things have gotten ridiculous. Felix Unger hums a few bars of a song nobody even remembers and it has to be replaced due to rights problems. Are you freakin kidding me? Further Maude releases are unreleased due to music rights. What? Somebody is overcharging Sony for a tiny handful of songs heard during the entire run. Sunset Strip and Hawaiian Eye are held up cause some moron wants too much money for a bunch of nightclub covers of standards anyone under 70 doesn't even remember. I'm truly tired of it. We classic TV fans pay the price because owners to the rights of obsolete archiaic music are so greedy. That's just flat not right.
Rant complete...
Good to see somebody getting pissed off at the rights holders of the music of these TV shows and not the hapless video companies releasing the shows on DVD. Those people are the true culprits.Frank Soyke said:A good example of how ridiculous these rights (music and otherwise) issues have gotten is Adventures In Paradise. Reportedly the Michener estate is asking too much money for the rights. Do these people have such inflated egos that they really think a distributor is going to pay them a gigantic amount of money for a show 95 percent of the public doesn't even remember let alone care about? Other than us, the niche market, who would buy it enough to garner a profit for them? A distributor would be completely stupid to pay an inflated price for a show like that. So instead of charging a reasonable price for the rights and taking the money and run, Micheners heirs want to play hardball and get nothing for the show. Stupidity. End result - We never get a chance to see the show again.
So did SCTV, in a skit called 'Stairways To Heaven' about a compilation LP composed of covers of Stairway To Heaven by artists as varied as Buffy Saint Marie to Rich Little. You can see the skit when the episode with the skit is rerun on TV, but the surviving members of the band have made it impossible to see it on DVD, so Second City Entertainment had to leave it off of the DVD. Sad.MatthewA said:IIRC, WKRP had Led Zeppelin's "Stairway to Heaven" originally, but now you can't license that song at any price.
And there lies the problem with any potential release of WKRP. The audio and video components for this show are not separate (The Wonder Years was shot on film but completed on video tape so it sounds like the audio and video portions are separate and therefore easier to edit). The show was shot on video tape. So, there is no way to remove the music from any given scene without removing the entire audio portion of said scene. Therefore, in order to do the release properly, the DVD producers would either have to get the original cast to re-record their dialogue so it could be re-inserted into the scene with new music or hire voice actors to mimic the original actors voices and record the dialogue. Then if there are any sound effects (bells, paper shuffling, etc) or foley work, all of that would have to be re-recorded and put back into the scene. All of which is going to cost money. Then if the dialogue revolves around the original song in a scene (like Pink Floyd's Dogs) then whole new dialogue will need to be written and then recorded. Again, either by the original cast or voice actors. More money added to the bottom line for the writers of the new dialogue.jimmyjet said:the replacement of music is one thing, but the editing of the dialog is a whole other issue - at least for you guys with wkrp.
As was explained above, the show is shot on video tape so there is onlyMishaLauenstein said:Just replace the music and leave the original dialogue.
As much as I love the show, I tend to agree. The main difference between WKRP and the Wonder Years is that great sales for the latter are almost a guaranteed slam dunk It is almost certain to recoup the massive investment Time-Life must have put in to license all that music. It's an iconic show that people have been clamoring for many yearsBrian Himes said:Ok, I've been following this and the Wonder Years discussion for quite a while. So, I'm going to chime in here .
And there lies the problem with any potential release of WKRP. The audio and video components for this show are not separate (The Wonder Years was shot on film but completed on video tape so it sounds like the audio and video portions are separate and therefore easier to edit). The show was shot on video tape. So, there is no way to remove the music from any given scene without removing the entire audio portion of said scene. Therefore, in order to do the release properly, the DVD producers would either have to get the original cast to re-record their dialogue so it could be re-inserted into the scene with new music or hire voice actors to mimic the original actors voices and record the dialogue. Then if there are any sound effects (bells, paper shuffling, etc) or foley work, all of that would have to be re-recorded and put back into the scene. All of which is going to cost money. Then if the dialogue revolves around the original song in a scene (like Pink Floyd's Dogs) then whole new dialogue will need to be written and then recorded. Again, either by the original cast or voice actors. More money added to the bottom line for the writers of the new dialogue.
Therefore, in my opinion, the only way for WKRP to really work on DVD is for 100% of the music to be included. There is just no cost effective way to eliminate it from the show. Unless they edit out entire scenes from the show, which as has been proven time and again, does not sit well with fans. Virtually every scene that takes place at the radio station contains music. Remember those speakers hanging on the wall in the lobby, the bull pit, Carlson's office and several other places throughout the station? Those speakers were always playing what ever was supposed to be being broadcast over the radio at that time. Most of the time it was music. Lose all of those scenes and there won't be any show left.
Considiering all of the above, I am still not convinced that WKRP will ever get released on DVD at any cost. Inspite of your whole Polyanna view, which I find admirable, that eventually everything will get worked out, is just not realistic. At least when it comes to WKRP. Continuing to compare this with the annoucement of The Wonder Years coming simply doesn't work. Which by the way, at this moment we don't know exactly how much, of the original music has been cleared. It has been stated that 'virtually' all of the music has been cleared. So at the moment we don't know what 'virtually' means. However, a fans view of how much music is 'virtually' and a studio's view of how much music is 'virtually' are probably going to be slightly different. The two shows are two different animals. What may work for one is certainly not going to work for the other by the shear nature of how the shows were originally produced.
Jimmy, while I really admire your optimism, Comparing WKRP to Star Trek????? C'mon man. Forget about not being in the same ballpark, that ain't even the same sport. I love WKRP but there is no comparison there.jimmyjet said:dont give up hope.
there is one thing that this show seems to have, and that is intense support from those that do like it.
which is exactly what star trek had, and look what happened with that show !!
Actually, if you look a bit closer to the details you will see the comparison still does not qualify. WKRP while a successful show during its original run and in syndication has only spawned one failed spin-off attempt that occurred in 1991. It's original run was 30+ years ago.jimmyjet said:LOL - just remember that star trek was not a hit show during its original run.
it took literally years of lobbying to get the studios to come out with anything about it.
if i recall, it was a movie of most of the original cast ?
people living today think of star trek as some monumental amount of tv. and it is, TODAY.
it wasnt for a long time.
so back then, if i had made the comment about star trek being liked by an intense support, and gave an example of some other big hit show -
you would have told me the same thing - star trek aint like that big hit show !!