Home Theater Forum › Home Theater Forum › Blu-ray, DVD, Streaming Video and Digital Downloads › Blu-ray › Official HTF Blu-ray Reviews › HTF BLU-RAY REVIEW: North by Northwest (50th Anniversary Edition) [Highly Recommended]
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

HTF BLU-RAY REVIEW: North by Northwest (50th Anniversary Edition) [Highly Recommended]

post #1 of 84
Thread Starter 
North by Northwest Blu-Ray 

North by Northwest (50th Anniversary Edition)

Release Date: November 3, 2009
Studio: Warner Brothers
Packaging/Materials: Single-disc Warner Digi-book
Year: 1959
Rating: NR
Running Time: 2:16:00
MSRP: $34.99

  THE FEATURE SPECIAL FEATURES
Video 1080p high definition 16x9 1.85:1 480i or 480p standard definition
Audio Dolby TrueHD: English 5.1 / Dolby Digital: English 5.1, French 1.0, Spanish 1.0, German 1.0, Italian 1.0, Portuguese 1.0 Stereo (5.1 and 2s) and mono
Subtitles English SDH, Spanish, French, Danish, German SDH, Italian, Finnish, Norwegian, Portuguese and Swedish English SDH, French, Spanish, German SDH, Italian and Portuguese

 

The Feature: 4.5/5

During a routine business lunch, Madison Avenue adman Roger Thornhill (Cary Grant) is mistaken for an American spy, sending him on a tumultuous journey that begins with his being kidnapped and almost killed. Though he narrowly escapes, no one believes his story, not even his mother, so he is forced to go it alone, pursued by the coolly sinister Philip Vandamm (James Mason), who's convinced he's more than what he is, and eventually the authorities for apparently murdering someone. If not for Eve Kendall (Eva Marie Saint), Thornhill would just be running for his life, but the beautiful stranger's moment of respite strengthens his resolve to fight his new enemies and clear his name. Though the truth becomes clearer with each lead he pursues, it turns out neither he nor Kendall are all that they seem. In his case it's from sheer necessity, the need to survive. In her case it's all by design.

To say "North by Northwest" is one of Director Alfred Hitchcock's best films is saying quite a lot, considering the company it keeps with "Rear Window," "Vertigo" and "The Birds" (to name just a few). Even without being sandwiched between two psychological thrillers on the Hitchcock filmography, one can see it is somewhat atypical of the work he's most known for, producing its excitement through action set pieces and choreographed romantic exchanges rather than convolutions of the mind. That's not to say it's in any ways conventional. If anything it's a perfect example of how an apparent "genre film" can be an outright great film, characterized by skillful direction, perfect casting and performances, and clever dialogue (though some of the humor in the first act falls flat). Though now 50 years old, the film certainly doesn't show its age - cosmetically, thanks to an impressive restoration that will please longtime fans, but also visually and narratively, evidence that good, cinematic storytelling is ultimately timeless.

Video Quality: 5/5

Presented in 1080p with the VC-1 codec, the film image fills the entirety of my 16:9 display (despite package labeling it as 1.85:1). The picture itself is blemish-free and exhibits consistently deep and stable black levels. Shadow delineation in pure black articles of clothing is often limited, but contrast can still be described as excellent, producing an image that feels both rich and dense. Deeply saturated colors and flesh tones add to the visual quality, the former looking especially remarkable in full daylight scenes. Wide angle vistas like the farmland crossroads, where the focus is so deep you can make out everything in the frame, show off the film's incredible sharpness and detail. Things may look a bit soft at times, particularly in the first several minutes, but by all appearances this is the nature of the cinematography rather than anything to do with the transfer, which also shows no signs of digital sharpening or noise reduction measures. In short, the film looks amazing. Titles a fraction of its age should be so fortunate.

Audio Quality: 4/5

The rear surround channels in the 5.1 Dolby TrueHD audio track provide light support for the score with some generally mild environmental and directional effects. The mix does become more aggressive in the crop dusting scene with seamless transitions for the airplane flyovers. Dialogue makes up the majority of the front soundstage activity and is consistently clear and detailed, the textures in Grant and Mason's vocal characteristics coming through nicely. Bernard Hermann's orchestral score is the greatest beneficiary of the lossless treatment with beautiful silkiness in the strings and powerful, sometimes surprising, depth to the tympani and double bass. And though LFE is non-existent, the airplane and fuel tanker explosion will definitely put the subwoofer to work. Overall it's an impressive presentation, yet another aspect of the film that transcends its age.

Special Features: 4.5/5

The special features package carries over the items from the 2000 DVD release and adds three additional documentaries. A handful of archival items and a commentary round out the overall solid feature set. Considering the quality of the film restoration and transfer, it would have been nice to have a featurette detailing the process, though I'm sure the information is readily available in industry magazines and websites (rumors of monks and nuns being involved notwithstanding).

Audio Commentary by Screenwriter Ernest Lehman: Lehman tends to describe on-screen action and is fairly measured in his comments, but he is forthcoming with his opinions, shares some interesting anecdotes, and provides insights into the writing process. However, with the slower pacing a more casual fan will probably get more out of the documentaries.

Cary Grant: A Class Apart (1:27:12, SD, 4x3): Produced in 2004 and aired as part of the PBS "American Masters" series, the documentary is a thorough exploration of Grant's professional and, to a lesser extent, personal life. The running theme throughout the piece is Grant's attitude toward and management of the "Cary Grant" persona, a canny awareness that many of today's legitimate stars and so-called celebrities would be wise to adopt.

The Master's Touch: Hitchcock's Signature Style (57:32, HD, 16x9): Produced in 2009, the documentary features directors like William Friedkin and Martin Scorsese, along with film critics and historians, identifying key characteristics of Hitchcock's work and what makes it so compelling. It offers a solid encapsulation of the director's particular storytelling methods, though is probably nothing new for longtime fans of his work.

Destination Hitchcock: The Making of North by Northwest (39:27, SD, 4x3): Produced in 2000, the somewhat sentimental retrospective is hosted by Eva Marie Saint and covers the requisite phases of the production, from development to publicity.

North by Northwest: One for the Ages (25:29, SD, 16x9): Screenwriter Christopher McQuarrie ("The Usual Suspects") and Directors Guillermo Del Toro ("Pan's Labyrinth"), William Friedkin ("The Exorcist"), Curtis Hanson ("The Hand that Rocks the Cradle"), and Francis Lawrence ("I Am Legend") dissect and analyze the film, highlighting key scenes and methods employed to tell the story. Of the more feature-centric pieces, I found this one the most interesting.

TV Spot (1:02, SD, 16x9):

A Guided Tour with Alfred Hitchcock Trailer (3:14, SD, 16x9): A tongue-in-cheek overview of the film with the director, presented as a travel promotion for the movie's locations.

Theatrical Trailer (2:13, SD, 16x9):

Stills Gallery (5:52, SD): Over forty photographs, primarily from the film's production but several from the production of "Destination Hitchcock."

Music-Only Audio Track: Presented in Dolby Digital 5.1 at 640 kbps, the switch to a lossy track is apparent, lacking much of the lossless option's smoothness and dynamic range. Though it's somewhat disappointing, the score is such a strong component of the film that in this case there's really not much benefit to the isolated track. Forced to choose between isolation and higher resolution, I recommend the latter.

Collectible Book: The nicely produced book-that-is-the-packaging includes cast and crew biographies, photographs and artwork and retrospective essays on the film.

Recap

The Feature: 4.5/5
Video Quality: 5/5
Audio Quality: 4/5
Special Features: 4.5/5
Overall Score (not an average): 4.5/5


One of Hitchcock's best films gets an excellent technical presentation and an equally impressive set of special features. For owners of the DVD the Blu-ray is a significant upgrade technically; the inclusion of in-depth documentaries further enhances the release. For both first-time purchase and the double-dip upgrade, the release is highly recommended.

Gear mentioned in this thread:

post #2 of 84
As an owner of the DVD, I'm going to order this right away. Thanks, Cameron!


Cees
post #3 of 84

Great review, Cameron!  I can't wait to see this one in high definition.

post #4 of 84
Are any of the extras docs in HD? The Master's Touch doc? Not that it would affect my purchase (already done), but we'd like to know these things from reviewers with preview copies.
post #5 of 84
Thread Starter 
They are all in standard def. The information is in the table of specs but I can repeat that info in the special features section if that would help.

EDIT: Format and aspect ratio information added to the special features area.
post #6 of 84

A great read, Cameron! It's almost exactly a year since we toured MPI and saw frames of this film being displayed at various workstations. When people talk about films being "in the pipeline", it's a long pipeline.

post #7 of 84
Thanks for the fine review, Cameron.

I eagerly anticipate this one.  Will probably pick it up very soon after release, if not during release week itself.

_Man_

 

post #8 of 84
I have been posting my comments in two other threads
related to this title.  I'll spare you this one and keep it brief.

The Blu-ray of NORTH BY NORTHWEST is just incredible.
The meticulous work done by MPI really shows here. Everyone

there should be taking a bow.  Last year's release of HOW
THE WEST  WAS WON and now this year's NORTH BY 
NORTHWEST have set the bar for all studios to beat as
far as how great classic film should look on this format.

post #9 of 84
Great review, I like the extras included that are new.

Out of curiosity, I checked the Best Buy price after looking at the price from the link above to Amazon. The Amazon price as of today is $24, a really good price. But Best Buy's site lists the blu ray on sale for $20.99. Hopefully the in-store price is the same, because I'd rather pick it up at the store then wait for Amazon. I'm sure Mike's Bargins thread will confirm. Perhaps Amazon will reset their price if BB is this low.

One thing though, historically, older films like this don't always get out on release day at Best Buy in favor of the hotter new films. Hopefully BB will have this on release day.

Can't wait. "Why are you so good to me!"
post #10 of 84
Best Buy currently has a 30% off all regular prices Blu-ray sale going on for the week, including pre-orders online. It's possible that the price may go up next week.
post #11 of 84
Thanks for the tip Ray. Saved me a couple of bucks over my Amazon pre-order price.
post #12 of 84
Thanks, Ray.  Nice heads up on the BB BD sale.  There are quite a few titles of interest there, not just NxNW.  Just wish I can go pick up NxNW right now instead of waiting til next week though.

_Man_
post #13 of 84
Another heads-up folks - Amazon has matched Best Buy's $20.99 price on this title as well a number of other preorders. Shipping with Amazon Prime or on orders over $25 is free.
post #14 of 84
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nelson Au View Post

...Best Buy's site lists the blu ray on sale for $20.99. Hopefully the in-store price is the same...
 


Unfortunately, it's not that cheap in next week's ad.
post #15 of 84
I still can't understand why the original mixes are ignored on some of these newly restored classics.
post #16 of 84
Travis, did you see an advanced copy of the BB weekly ad? I am gambling this web price/sale price will still be in effect next week. They have matched the website price for me at the store. 
post #17 of 84

Amazon lowered their price to $20.99 (to match BB?) after I had already pre-ordered it at $24.99, but I cancelled and re-ordered at the lower price. I don't trust BB to hold that price until next week. But I did take advantage of that $10 off deal on the new Star Trek movie, if you add one of the previous movies - both for $30 total (with tax).

post #18 of 84
Quote:
Originally Posted by Hollywoodaholic View Post

Amazon lowered their price to $20.99 (to match BB?) after I had already pre-ordered it at $24.99, but I cancelled and re-ordered at the lower price. I don't trust BB to hold that price until next week. But I did take advantage of that $10 off deal on the new Star Trek movie, if you add one of the previous movies - both for $30 total (with tax).


I was tempted to order @ $24.99, because I absolutely have to have this. But I really expected some sort of price drop and jumped on the $20.99 deal and pre-ordered. I've done the pre-order/cancel/re-order thing too many times with Amazon. With Prime and free 2-day shipping, I should get this on Tuesday.
post #19 of 84
Quote:
Originally Posted by David_B_K View Post

I was tempted to order @ $24.99, because I absolutely have to have this. But I really expected some sort of price drop and jumped on the $20.99 deal and pre-ordered. I've done the pre-order/cancel/re-order thing too many times with Amazon. With Prime and free 2-day shipping, I should get this on Tuesday.

 

I wonder if Amazon might still stick NxNW into the daily Gold Box deals just in time for release day.   Today's deals (for me anyway) include a few recent BD releases plus Inglourious Basterds.  If NxNW gets included in the next couple days (before BB possibly ends the sale price), you can save another buck on it w/ yet another cancel/re-order.

_Man_
post #20 of 84
I'm going to gamble that Best Buy will retain that sale price for North by Northwest till next week. If they don't have that price in the store, I'll have them match their web page price, which they've done for me before.

The other option is to pre-order it from the BB web site for in-store pick-up.
post #21 of 84
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nelson Au View Post

The other option is to pre-order it from the BB web site for in-store pick-up.
 

Why not just do that?  That's what I would do.  Not much point in going to the B&M store looking for it and possibly have them be out-of-stock or priced higher, if you can basically reserve it online for pickup at that price.  And near as I can tell, cancelling seems completely pain-free, if you need to do that later.

_Man_
post #22 of 84
So getting this, awesome review thanks Cam!
post #23 of 84
Pre-order it today for pick up next week before the price goes up. I've seen the weekly ad for Best Buy for next week and the price goes up to $24.99

Quote:
Originally Posted by Nelson Au View Post

I'm going to gamble that Best Buy will retain that sale price for North by Northwest till next week. If they don't have that price in the store, I'll have them match their web page price, which they've done for me before.

The other option is to pre-order it from the BB web site for in-store pick-up.
 
post #24 of 84
Okay, pre-ordered at BB. First time I ever did this at BB. Now I hope they will actually have it in-stock on Tuesday! Waiting now for confirmation email that it is in stock for pick-up.
post #25 of 84
Quote:
Originally Posted by Man-Fai Wong View Post



I wonder if Amazon might still stick NxNW into the daily Gold Box deals just in time for release day.   Today's deals (for me anyway) include a few recent BD releases plus Inglourious Basterds.  If NxNW gets included in the next couple days (before BB possibly ends the sale price), you can save another buck on it w/ yet another cancel/re-order.

_Man_

I got the "your order has shipped" e-mail on Thursday, so too late to cancel/reorder. However, the same thing happened on Snow White, and they automatically issued a $5 credit, just like the old days.
post #26 of 84
I got an email confirmation for my pre-order of NxNW at Best Buy, so it worked with the price locked in at $20 before tax. My first time doing this!

And I see that Mike's Bargain page shows Best Buy selling it at $24 as you guys said it would be. And I check Amazon and they dropped it to $19.99.

Must be some guys at Amazon and Best Buy watching each other's prices and doing a Spy vs. Spy thing in order to beat each other. Pretty amazing for us!
post #27 of 84
Amazon shipped my order and credited me the extra dollar below my $20.99 order. They do run a tight ship there.
post #28 of 84
BB usually can't compete with Amazon; not surprised about the lower price at Amazon.  I can't wait to see this film in two weeks....
post #29 of 84
"He's assembling the General Assembly..."

Nice review, one of my favourite films from my favourite director.

Looks like I've gone Blu just in time to pick this up!
post #30 of 84
Just picked this up today.  It looked fantastic on the most recent DVD special edition...I can't imagien how it will look on BR.  Very much looking forward to it!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Official HTF Blu-ray Reviews

Gear mentioned in this thread:

Home Theater Forum › Home Theater Forum › Blu-ray, DVD, Streaming Video and Digital Downloads › Blu-ray › Official HTF Blu-ray Reviews › HTF BLU-RAY REVIEW: North by Northwest (50th Anniversary Edition) [Highly Recommended]