Jeff Cooper
Senior HTF Member
Getting off the topic of Star Wars for a moment or two...
I can't speak for anyone else, but my reaction (which I have discussed before) is that while I loved a lot about the show, I absolutely hated how the series Lost ended during my first viewing of the series. During the early years of the show my recollection was that the show runners "swore up and down" that the cast had not died and that this was not purgatory or something akin to that. Then later, season six comes along and that is essentially what we get as a resolution for the series. I honestly felt like the show essentially lied to me, although the reality was that they were sort of making it up as they went along. This kind of ties in to my criticism of Lindelof and his failure (at times) to deliver a meaningful resolution.
I remember Craig Ferguson saying (after the finale) that he felt like the writers had come and taken a dump on his front porch. A sentiment we had in common.
I eventually revisited the entire series (on Blu-Ray) with a friend who had never experienced the show and I was much more sanguine about the entire thing and actually enjoyed the series a lot more the second time around.
Long way of saying "yes" and "no".
- Walter.
Errrr, wow. I think you need to watch it a 3rd time because....
They weren't dead or in purgatory. Literally the only parts of the entire series where they were dead and in Limbo was the 'flash sideways' parts of the last season. Literally everything else in the entire show happened in real life where they were very much alive.