MartinTeller
Screenwriter
- Joined
- Feb 26, 2002
- Messages
- 1,721
I think some people are being a little over-dramatic with their scoring....
I am grading my lists as standalone films, not in comparison to what I would consider the greatest films ever made. (If that makes sense).It does, however Jim_K disallowed half points, so I need to distinguish between some films by being overly harsh on scoring.
0 absolutely irredeemable (not awarded yet; wait till TTMR )
[1-3] awful->mediocre
[4-9] good->superb
10 flawless (not awarded yet; reserved for the best of the best)
I'm in agreement with Jim's grading guidelines, and there will likely be only a few films that I will rate below a 5 in this poll.Nice to hear, I was starting to feel a little generous after seeing some of the scores. I think so far i've only rated 1 or 2 films below 5. I'll just follow Jim's score line (which was similar to how I score anyway), since it is his thread it makes it a little easier to see what he is after in terms of results.