Directors The Great Films HTF Scorecard Vote (1 Viewer)

[Brook K]

Blazing Saddles - 8
The 400 Blows - 9
An American in Paris - 7
McCabe & Mrs. Miller - abstain
Sophie's Choice - abstain
Ocean's Eleven (2001) - 5
What's Eating Gilbert Grape - 8
Dances with Wolves - 5
Adaptation - 7
The Lion King - abstain
Psycho - 10
The Right Stuff - 6

 

[Jim_K]

Batch #4

The Wicker Man
Tootsie
Three Colors: Blue
Swingers
A Shot in the Dark
The Quiet American
One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest
Monsters, Inc.
Mississippi Burning
Lone Star
Freaks
Edward Scissorhands
Dead Poets Society
Brazil
The Big Heat
Best in Show
The Blue Angel
25th Hour
Midnight Run
Vertigo

 

[Nick Sievers]

Batch #4

The Wicker Man - 7
Tootsie - 3
Three Colors: Blue - 10 (I expect Dome to give it a good score as well)
Swingers - 7
A Shot in the Dark - Haven't Seen
The Quiet American - 7
One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest - 10
Monsters, Inc. - 8
Mississippi Burning - Been to long
Lone Star - Haven't Seen
Freaks - Haven't Seen
Edward Scissorhands - 9
Dead Poets Society - Been to long
Brazil - 9
The Big Heat - Haven't Seen
Best in Show - 7
The Blue Angel - Haven't Seen
25th Hour - 8
Midnight Run - 6
Vertigo - 10

 

[george kaplan]

Tootsie - 1
A Shot in the Dark - 9
One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest - 8
Monsters, Inc. - 10
Freaks - 8
Dead Poets Society - 5
Brazil - 4
The Big Heat - 9
Best in Show - 0
The Blue Angel - 5
Vertigo - 10

 

[Brad Porter]

Batch #4
10 Vertigo
9 Lone Star
9 Brazil
8 Midnight Run
8 One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest
8 Monsters, Inc.
8 Best in Show
8 Swingers
7 Tootsie
7 Freaks
5 Dead Poets Society

Abstain
The Wicker Man
Three Colors: Blue
A Shot in the Dark
The Quiet American
Edward Scissorhands
Mississippi Burning
The Big Heat
The Blue Angel
25th Hour

Brad

 

[Brian Lawrence]

The Wicker Man - 8
Tootsie - 4
Three Colors: Blue -8
One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest - 9
Monsters, Inc. - 8
Mississippi Burning - 7
Lone Star - 7
Freaks - 6
Edward Scissorhands - 9
Dead Poets Society - 0
Brazil - 7
The Big Heat - 7
Best in Show - 7
25th Hour - 6
Midnight Run - 6
Vertigo - 10

 

[ErikG]

Batch #4

The Wicker Man--2
Tootsie--7
Three Colors: Blue--2
Swingers--abstain
A Shot in the Dark--6
The Quiet American--abstain
One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest--2
Monsters, Inc.--4
Mississippi Burning--4
Lone Star--5
Freaks--1
Edward Scissorhands--3
Dead Poets Society--7
Brazil--3
The Big Heat--abstain
Best in Show--abstain
The Blue Angel--abstain
25th Hour--6
Midnight Run--6
Vertigo--5

 

[Arman]

Batch #4

Tootsie 5
Three Colors: Blue 10
Swingers 5
The Quiet American 7
One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest 7
Monsters, Inc. 5
Lone Star 6
Edward Scissorhands 4
Dead Poets Society 4
Brazil 5
Best in Show 5
The Blue Angel 6
25th Hour 7
Vertigo 10

 

[MartinTeller]

8 The Wicker Man
3 Tootsie
7 Swingers
6 The Quiet American
10 One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest
9 Monsters, Inc.
7 Mississippi Burning
8 Freaks
6 Edward Scissorhands
4 Dead Poets Society
10 Brazil
9 Best in Show
5 25th Hour
7 Midnight Run
10 Vertigo

 

[Bill J]

THREE:
Blazing Saddles - 7
The 400 Blows - 9
An American in Paris - 7
McCabe & Mrs. Miller - abstain
Sophie's Choice - 8
Ocean's Eleven (2001) - 8
What's Eating Gilbert Grape - 7
Dances with Wolves - 10
Adaptation - 10
The Lion King - 7
Psycho - 9
The Right Stuff - 10

FOUR:
The Wicker Man - 7
Tootsie - 3
Three Colors: Blue - 9
Swingers - 4
A Shot in the Dark - 7
The Quiet American - abstain
One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest - 9
Monsters, Inc. - abstain
Mississippi Burning - 7
Lone Star - 8
Freaks - abstain
Edward Scissorhands - 4
Dead Poets Society - 3
Brazil - 4
The Big Heat - 9
Best in Show - abstain
The Blue Angel - 6
25th Hour - 10
Midnight Run - 7
Vertigo - 10

 

[Rand]

Batch #4

abstain The Wicker Man -
7 Tootsie
abstain Three Colors: Blue
8 Swingers
abstain A Shot in the Dark
7 The Quiet American
9 One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest
abstain Monsters, Inc.
abstain Mississippi Burning
8 Lone Star
8 Freaks
8 Edward Scissorhands
7 Dead Poets Society
8 Brazil
9 The Big Heat
abstain Best in Show
6 The Blue Angel
abstain 25th Hour
abstain Midnight Run
10 Vertigo

 

[Andrew_Sch]

I'd like to get in on this. I know I've missed a lot, but I can PM my votes for all the rounds I've missed and catch up over the next few days, if that's okay. Just let me know.

 

[Rob P S]

Batch #4

Tootsie - 8
Lone Star - 9
Edward Scissorhands - 8
Dead Poets Society - 9

 

[Dome Vongvises]

(I expect Dome to give it a good score as well)

Is that what they say?

Batch #4

The Wicker Man - 7
Tootsie - 6
Three Colors: Blue - 3
Swingers - 7
A Shot in the Dark - abstain
The Quiet American - abstain
One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest - 9
Monsters, Inc. - 9
Mississippi Burning - abstain
Lone Star - abstain
Freaks - abstain
Edward Scissorhands - 8
Dead Poets Society - 7
Brazil - 8
The Big Heat - abstain
Best in Show - abstain
The Blue Angel - abstain
25th Hour - abstain
Midnight Run - abstain
Vertigo - 9

 

[John C. Wilson]

Batch #3

Blazing Saddles 10
The 400 Blows 2
An American in Paris 7
McCabe & Mrs. Miller 1
Sophie's Choice 3
Ocean's Eleven (2001) 6
What's Eating Gilbert Grape 4
Dances with Wolves 9
Adaptation 5
The Lion King 10
Psycho 10
The Right Stuff 8

Batch #4

The Wicker Man 0
Tootsie 0
Three Colors: Blue 1
Swingers 2
A Shot in the Dark 9
The Quiet American (which one?)
One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest 6
Monsters, Inc. 10
Mississippi Burning 3
Lone Star (which one?)
Freaks 7
Edward Scissorhands 4
Dead Poets Society 5
Brazil 4
The Big Heat 8
Best in Show 0
The Blue Angel 4 (assuming 1930)
25th Hour 0
Midnight Run 3
Vertigo 10

 

[Brook K]

The Wicker Man - 9
Tootsie - 6
Three Colors: Blue - 8
Swingers - 7
A Shot in the Dark - abstain
The Quiet American - 4
One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest - 8
Monsters, Inc. - 3
Mississippi Burning - 6
Lone Star - 9
Freaks - 9
Edward Scissorhands - 10
Dead Poets Society - 7
Brazil - 4
The Big Heat - abstain
Best in Show - 6
The Blue Angel - 10
25th Hour - 9
Midnight Run - abstain
Vertigo - 10

 

[Simon_Lepine]

The Wicker Man - 8
Tootsie - 6
Three Colors: Blue - 9
The Quiet American - 7
One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest - 7
Monsters, Inc. - 8
Mississippi Burning - 7
Lone Star - 7
Edward Scissorhands - 6
Dead Poets Society - 5
Brazil - 10
The Big Heat - 8
25th Hour - 8
Midnight Run - 7
Vertigo -10

 

[Justin_S]

Batch #2

Good Will Hunting- 3
Red River- 8
Sleuth- 6
Clerks- 6
The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring- 8
Stand by Me- 7
The Quiet Man- 7
MASH- 6
E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial- 5
The Godfather- 8
The Shawshank Redemption- 10
The Terminator- 7

Batch #3

Blazing Saddles- 6
The 400 Blows- 8
An American in Paris- 6
McCabe & Mrs. Miller- Abstain
Sophie's Choice- Abstain
Ocean's Eleven (2001)- 4
What's Eating Gilbert Grape- 7
Dances with Wolves- 9
Adaptation- 6
The Lion King- 5
Psycho- 9
The Right Stuff- 6

Batch #4

The Wicker Man- 10
Tootsie- 6
Three Colors: Blue- 10
Swingers- 7
A Shot in the Dark- 6
The Quiet American- 7
One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest- 5
Monsters, Inc.- 5
Mississippi Burning- 8
Lone Star- 7
Freaks- 10
Edward Scissorhands- 5
Dead Poets Society- 6
Brazil- 10
The Big Heat- Abstain
Best in Show- 10
The Blue Angel- Abstain
25th Hour- 9
Midnight Run- 7
Vertigo- 10

 

[Nick Sievers]

I'm glad to see there are a few of us who consider Edward Scissorhands an excellent film.

How is everyone rating films? I know Arman explained his criteria but to give films like 25 Hour a Zero, to me this means the film is beyond god-awful and possibly in the worst ever film category.

I am grading my lists as standalone films, not in comparison to what I would consider the greatest films ever made. (If that makes sense).

1 - Awful
2-3 - Bad, not recommended
4-5 - Below Average
6 - Average
7 - Above Average
8 - Good, Recommended Viewing
9 - Outstanding
10- Excellent, Essential viewing

 

[Bill McA]

The Wicker Man - 10
Tootsie - 1
Three Colors: Blue - 10
Swingers - 7
A Shot in the Dark - 6
The Quiet American - abstain
One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest - 10
Monsters, Inc. - 8
Mississippi Burning - 6
Lone Star - 8
Freaks - 9
Edward Scissorhands - 7
Dead Poets Society - 7
Brazil - 10
The Big Heat - 6
Best in Show - 7
The Blue Angel - 7
25th Hour - 9
Midnight Run - 6
Vertigo - 9