- Joined
- Feb 8, 1999
- Messages
- 18,437
- Real Name
- Robert Harris
Having always been an admirer of Lasse Hallstrom's work, I've held his Salmon Fishing in the Yemen, which came out in July on the back burner, as I wanted to be able to sit down and view the entire film.
Now that I've seen it, I can say that it isn't quite what I expected. Based upon what Variety calls a "side-splitting political sendup" by author Paul Torday, the film comes off as neither "side-slitting" nor a "political sendup."
Rather, through Mr. Hallstrom's vision, the film seems more of a modern fable about good, evil, and relationships. Apparently, many people who read the book, which had its biggest readership in the UK, were expecting something different, and reviews reacted in that way.
Having not read the book, my reactions were positive, viewing this as a sweet little film, essentially about good people trying to do the near impossible, against huge odds.
I normall don't go into cast, but in this case, I found Ewan McGregor and Emily Blunt always key perfect, and Amr Waked, an Egyptian actor, who was likewise superb. In more ways that merely his kafia and robes, he reminded me of all the positive attributes of Omar Sharif's Ali, and Alec Guinness' wise Feisal.
Having now read the reviews... Variety places Kristin Scott Thomas's character in the vein of something out of Dr. Strangelove, I'll have to find the time to read the source.
Photographed in 35mm scope, and finished via a 2k DI, the resultant Blu-ray, should look like the original. It does look and sound (DTS-MA) superb in all respects.
Recommended.
RAH
Now that I've seen it, I can say that it isn't quite what I expected. Based upon what Variety calls a "side-splitting political sendup" by author Paul Torday, the film comes off as neither "side-slitting" nor a "political sendup."
Rather, through Mr. Hallstrom's vision, the film seems more of a modern fable about good, evil, and relationships. Apparently, many people who read the book, which had its biggest readership in the UK, were expecting something different, and reviews reacted in that way.
Having not read the book, my reactions were positive, viewing this as a sweet little film, essentially about good people trying to do the near impossible, against huge odds.
I normall don't go into cast, but in this case, I found Ewan McGregor and Emily Blunt always key perfect, and Amr Waked, an Egyptian actor, who was likewise superb. In more ways that merely his kafia and robes, he reminded me of all the positive attributes of Omar Sharif's Ali, and Alec Guinness' wise Feisal.
Having now read the reviews... Variety places Kristin Scott Thomas's character in the vein of something out of Dr. Strangelove, I'll have to find the time to read the source.
Photographed in 35mm scope, and finished via a 2k DI, the resultant Blu-ray, should look like the original. It does look and sound (DTS-MA) superb in all respects.
Recommended.
RAH