Dome Vongvises
Senior HTF Member
- Joined
- May 13, 2001
- Messages
- 8,172
I hear it every now and then, but are there filmmakers/academics that still haven't embraced DVD?
Yes, I would definately cast a vote for Woody Allen. He seems completely uninterested in the DVDs being produced of his films.I don't think a filmmaker needs to be interested in extras in order to be considered an embracer of the format. Allen, for example, is an outspoken OAR proponent. For him, the DVD format may simply be a way of presenting his films in the proper manner to greatest extent that current technology offers. Given that many DVD enthusiasts who post here also rate the A/V quality of a DVD as the most important element and do not care for extras, I think Allen represents a certain segment of DVD enthusiasts. As such, it seems to me that he has embraced DVD as way to see his films. May take on the issue may be incorrect, but I think it a fallacy to suggest that a director who doesn't want his films to have extras on DVD has also necessarily refused to embrace the format.
DJ
David Lynch can do as he please, and I certainly respect his opinion to do so, but I call his logic into question.Dan Brecher said:Quote:
but I don't think it's fair to the filmmakers to determine the year's best films by seeing them on home video.I'm having a hard time understanding this, but you got to help me here; is this a question of OAR or presentation?
I can barely make a difference in what "film" looks like compared to compressed video files, but can you exactly explain how big of a difference this is and why it makes a difference to see a movie in a theater setting (as opposed to alone with your own thoughts in a home theater).
Re: Dr. Capser
He could be the nicest guy in the world, but I couldn't help but feel that he was being awful rude to the AFI. It wasn't like the AFI was being rude to him. But then again, academics/scholars tend to scoff/get annoyed at the most strangest things.
Woody Allen?Well... except for Annie Hall, all of his films on DVD are 16x9 with excellent picture/audio quality (or poor quality, to mono-phobes)