Chris
Senior HTF Member
- Joined
- Jul 4, 1997
- Messages
- 6,788
I've thought about this all day, and launched into a rebuttal right off the bat, but I too tend to agree with the viewpoint that Ron's review ended far too harsh, and instead of evaluating the overall product of both, it played up the "slam-bang" conclusion of "why bother with X" this seems to bely a lot of people who simply have different musical tastes who may be served by a different format.
I talked to two coworkers today, one with XM and one with Sirius (I also have Sirius, as I've noted) about what made it important to us; and we all had, in my mind, very solid reasoning for why we preferred where we were at and would not consider changing. Too much of the programming I desire I can't replicate on XM. Same is true of those on XM in reference to Sirius.
The best advice I could give anyone investigating in satellite radio is that both formats have gigantic advantages over FM radio, and dependant on your musical tastes, have advantages over each other. Pick and choose for yourself. Debate the strengths and weakenesses. Because as it sits, this is really a "coke/pepsi" type debate, both products will have advocates, and I think it's good that we have two competitors in the marketspace rather then one
I talked to two coworkers today, one with XM and one with Sirius (I also have Sirius, as I've noted) about what made it important to us; and we all had, in my mind, very solid reasoning for why we preferred where we were at and would not consider changing. Too much of the programming I desire I can't replicate on XM. Same is true of those on XM in reference to Sirius.
The best advice I could give anyone investigating in satellite radio is that both formats have gigantic advantages over FM radio, and dependant on your musical tastes, have advantages over each other. Pick and choose for yourself. Debate the strengths and weakenesses. Because as it sits, this is really a "coke/pepsi" type debate, both products will have advocates, and I think it's good that we have two competitors in the marketspace rather then one