Richard Michael Clark
Second Unit
- Joined
- Oct 5, 2001
- Messages
- 373
Can anyone answer a query I have about Alliance Atlantis releases.
I am in the UK and get most of my R1 discs from etailers that source their product from Canadian suppliers.
Many New Line, Universal & Dimension US releases (and others I'm sure!) seem to be released in Canada by Alliance Atlantis.
I've read various complaints leveled at this company over the quality of their releases (the subtitle problem on "Bowling for Columbine" being the latest) and just wondered if I have anything to worry about when buying "major" titles?
Basically, is the quality of the CONTENT the same as the domestic US release? I am not so much bothered by bilingual packaging but rather more concered with the video & audio quality - eg. Can I be sure that the video quality of "Lord of the Rings" or "Final Destination 2" is the same on the Alliance disc as the New Line disc? (baring in mind that both releases also carry the New Line name). I do notice that some disc features are different in these releases (audio tracks etc).
Recent titles I have from Alliance Atlantis include:
- both releases of "LOTR: fellowship" (2 disc and 4 disc boxset with bookends). French 2.0 audio track replaces English 2.0.
- "Below" - trailer included on Dimension release removed.
- "Far from heaven" - seems to be the same as Universal release?
- "Final Destination 2" - billed as Newline Infinifilm (French 2.0 replaces English 2.0 & no English subtitles)
etc...
I always buy discs based on reviews and I've always assumed that these Canadian releases are simple ports of the US releases and would have the same picture & audio quality. But, am I wrong?
Cheers
Rich
I am in the UK and get most of my R1 discs from etailers that source their product from Canadian suppliers.
Many New Line, Universal & Dimension US releases (and others I'm sure!) seem to be released in Canada by Alliance Atlantis.
I've read various complaints leveled at this company over the quality of their releases (the subtitle problem on "Bowling for Columbine" being the latest) and just wondered if I have anything to worry about when buying "major" titles?
Basically, is the quality of the CONTENT the same as the domestic US release? I am not so much bothered by bilingual packaging but rather more concered with the video & audio quality - eg. Can I be sure that the video quality of "Lord of the Rings" or "Final Destination 2" is the same on the Alliance disc as the New Line disc? (baring in mind that both releases also carry the New Line name). I do notice that some disc features are different in these releases (audio tracks etc).
Recent titles I have from Alliance Atlantis include:
- both releases of "LOTR: fellowship" (2 disc and 4 disc boxset with bookends). French 2.0 audio track replaces English 2.0.
- "Below" - trailer included on Dimension release removed.
- "Far from heaven" - seems to be the same as Universal release?
- "Final Destination 2" - billed as Newline Infinifilm (French 2.0 replaces English 2.0 & no English subtitles)
etc...
I always buy discs based on reviews and I've always assumed that these Canadian releases are simple ports of the US releases and would have the same picture & audio quality. But, am I wrong?
Cheers
Rich