What's new

what exactly is the difference between 2 channel stereo and 5 channel stereo? (1 Viewer)

Mike Matthews

Stunt Coordinator
Joined
Aug 1, 2003
Messages
140
all i know is that i'm loving listening to music when it's flowing out of all my speakers

however, i hear that 2 channel is better, quality-wise

what exactly is the difference, other than the fact that the tunes are coming out of all the speakers as opposed to just two
 

DavidES

Stunt Coordinator
Joined
Jun 23, 2003
Messages
116
One answer to your difference question, IMHO, has to do with the audio image. 2ch can only go so far. The image only extends from the sides of your head to the front where the speakers are, only if you sit in the exact center and the speaker/seating is just right. Not conducive to having company over to listen.
Multichannel can extend the front-back image to behind you and sound more balanced to your friends sitting off-axis. Now the current 5.1 setup is a little flawed since it's for the movies where you have a visual world setup in front of you, but it does a decent job on audio-only if the source has been mixed right.

Multichannel can give the artists more options to work with if they wish.

In reference to the quality, multi should be better due to higher sampling rates and deeper bit depth giving a lower noise floor, more dynamic range, and more detailed high frequencies.

This might be a good read for ya.

Maybe another way to put it is that multichannel, if done right on both mixing and home setup, would allow you to feel more immersed in the artist's audio world and not just listening to it since you get more of the 360 degrees around you. Does that make some kind of sense to you?

When you sit down for that desperate hit of music ;) , turn down the lights, relax, close your eyes and escape reality for a while.
 

brentl

Senior HTF Member
Joined
May 7, 1999
Messages
2,921
Pretty much a way to fill up the room with sound.

Denon has this on there receivers and it works great.

I'd say it's for non critical listening only.

Brent
 

RobWil

Supporting Actor
Joined
Mar 17, 2003
Messages
733
5 Channel stereo is different than multichannel formats. In 5 channel stereo it's just like having 2 sets of stereo speakers, one in front and one in back....the same exact information is coming out of the rear speakers. I'm not sure what comes out of the center since it can't play in stereo. So it depends on if you're talking about 'multichannel' or what they call '5 channel stereo', so when you ask:
what exactly is the difference, other than the fact that the tunes are coming out of all the speakers as opposed to just two
That IS the only difference!
 

Bob McElfresh

Senior HTF Member
Joined
May 22, 1999
Messages
5,182
however, i hear that 2 channel is better, quality-wise
I suspect this is a bit of old-fogey snob attitude.

Here is something a salesman told me that still feels true:

"Music is about accuracy, but home theater is about impact."

When you talk to audiophiles (music lovers) they demand as close to total accuracy as possible. This means if they play a CD (which only has 2 channels), then anything more than 2 speakers producing sound is considered wrong to them.

Many receivers will take 2-channel music and perform various 'tricks' to route the sound to 5.1 speakers. Some of these are kind of a gimmick (like "Hall" and "Church" settings), but others do a very good job.

So just be aware that there is a bit of 'attitude' against 5-channel sound (unless it's a 5-channel disk of course). But it's YOUR system, dont let anybody shame you into thinking you are doing something wrong.
 

Mike Matthews

Stunt Coordinator
Joined
Aug 1, 2003
Messages
140
:emoji_thumbsup:

thanks guys - good information. i really like listening in 5 channel stereo...but sometimes i switch back and forth to regular stereo just for kicks. i've only had my system for a couple days, so i'm still experimenting!
 

Citizen87645

Reviewer
Senior HTF Member
Joined
May 9, 2002
Messages
13,058
Real Name
Cameron Yee
When I first got my receiver I liked the 5 channel mode too, but after awhile I got tired of it. For my receiver bass is fuller in stereo mode.
 

Jason GT

Second Unit
Joined
Dec 12, 2002
Messages
452
I've got multichannel stereo on my AVR as well, but I don't use it. The owner's manual states that the algorithm for multichannel is simple: The left and right signals are also sent to the left and right surrounds respectively, and the center channel gets a summed signal of the L+R.

As for multichannel audio (SACD/DVD-A) - I have no experience with it. The closest I have is Logic7, and IMO the thing that is lost with L7 (and I'm guessing multichannel audio) is due to the use of a CC there is resulting loss of center image. Even with a set of inexpensive speakers, the delicacy and accuracy of a stereo image is far beyond what can be achieved with a CC. IMO of course :)
 

ChrisWiggles

Senior HTF Member
Joined
Aug 19, 2002
Messages
4,791
multichannel 5.1 music can be amazing, whether from just DVD (dts/dd) or SACD and DVD-A. I prefer very conservative mixes, as it's much more real.

Multi-channel stereo... is.... cool for a little bit, but there's just no imaging going on, it's just a lot more oopmh. Your're just getting a folded L-R mix in the center, and the same L and R out the surrounds. Fun for parties, but anathema to the magic of 2-channel music. Expanded DSP stereo, CAN sound very nice indeed, or, unfortunately with most recievers, very gimmicky and as degrading as all/multi-channel stereo. If done well, though, it can definitely add something to "plain" stereo. (I say plain with great trepidation, stereo is FAR from plain)

My .02, do what sounds best to you.
 

BrentPollard

Second Unit
Joined
Dec 18, 2001
Messages
445
Play stereo music in stereo, that's how it was mixed. But as stated above 5 channel stereo does fill the room. If you have large mains just crank up the volume in stereo.;)
 

KendallT

Agent
Joined
Aug 28, 2002
Messages
28
With Denon, the "5 Channel Stereo" is just what RobWil and JasonT stated, it's an algorithim Denon uses to route a normal 2-channel source (like a normal CD or a record) into all 5 of your speakers. It is NOT surround sound in the sense of DVD-Audio, SACD or even a 5.1 mix from a DVD Video which are discretely recorded to take advanrtage of the extra channels.

I use it sometimes on my Denon 3803, just do what sounds good to you. But, when I play a DVD-Audio disc or a 5.1 DVD video I never use the "5 Channel Stereo" mode as it would completly miss the point.

Happy Listening!
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Sign up for our newsletter

and receive essential news, curated deals, and much more







You will only receive emails from us. We will never sell or distribute your email address to third party companies at any time.

Latest Articles

Forum statistics

Threads
357,065
Messages
5,129,944
Members
144,283
Latest member
Nielmb
Recent bookmarks
0
Top