Rob alva
Grip
- Joined
- Jan 25, 2002
- Messages
- 18
First of all, Hello to everyone at the HT site. I've been on a testing frenzy the past few months. I was the proud owner of three of the best subwoofers in the world.
1- Dual 20-39 CS+/S1000
2- Earthquake MKIV-15
3- Velodyne HGS-18
Before these I owned a Polk PSW 650. First, the SVS package. After finding the best position (both corner-loaded up front) & calibrating via test tones and spl meter, I was initially some-what dissatisfied. After growing accustomed to "TRUE, CLEAN BASS", I quickly fell in love with them. I felt like a little kid after recieving that bicycle for x-mas. These subs are so quick and accurate. Only I didn't "TRULY KNOW" to what extent until later on. However, I did find their limits quickly. Since they play so low & clean, you can bottom them out easily (if you are a bass-head like myself). Oh, by-the-way. My HT area is huge with 18ft ceilings & a loft.
Mr. Earthquake was next. I was immediately impressed with it's small size and rugged finish (A+ rating). This sub is entirely different from the SVS subs. It has the most powerful amp I have ever experienced in a HT sub...PERIOD!!! Lights would dim and I could only stand the volume on the sub at 3, maybe 4 tops (out of 10)!!! Highly under-rated amp (it MUST-BE high-current or something)! This sub goes very low, but when you reach 25HZ and below, the svs subs & Velodyne are MUCH cleaner & play lower, faster! The earthquake just seems to "rumble a lot compared to the other two below 25HZ. The earthquake sounded best behind the seating position for some reason. This sub has a single 15" driver & a 15" passive radiator. These combined produce the most VIOLENT BASS I've ever heard or felt...PERIOD!!! Leaves the SVS & Velodyne in the dust above 25HZ! Forget the "bass-shakers,etc". This sub is simply put,"the devil, himself" when it comes to moving you!
Now the Velodyne is an interesting sub. It is huge, and beautiful. The built-in amp is rated at 1250 rms/3000 max! Uhhhhh...yeah, ok. Don't get me wrong, it is a powerful amp but the earthquake amp is in a league of its own! The HGS-18 did prove to cover the ground in-between both the svs & earthquake subs. It played VERY, VERY LOW! It was VERY quick! Amazing, considering it is an 18" driver! It put out the "biggest bass" I've heard in a HT sub. That term I used is sort of hard to explain. The bass just seemed like it covered more area, especially when position behind the seating area. It was almost as quick as the svs subs & much, much faster than the earthquake. It sounded like someone had a "huge air-cannon" up front and felt "like a giant just sat on you" when positioned behind the seating area. However, I had the gain on this sub maxed out.
Final analysis: For super clean, super quick, & natural low bass, but not as much Body-moving bass as the other two, go with SVS 20-39CS+ subs.
For "No Holds Barred", "Simply VIOLENT" 25HZ + bass, the earthquake is KING-KONG here! Don't get me wrong, this sub will play way below 20HZ. The sound just isn't as gratifying as the other two.
For the best of both worlds, choose Velodyne HGS-18. It plays low, almost as clean as the svs subs, but gives you more shake. I must also add that it sounds GREAT up front & just as good in back. Very versitile. The SVS subs had little impact behind the seating position in my HT area!
I am probably going to keep the Velodyne HGS-18!
I hope this has helped everyone still uncertain about which sub to choose. These are 3 of the best subs $ can buy. All three are superb, but each is very different. It all depends on what "YOU" want!
Thank you
Rob
1- Dual 20-39 CS+/S1000
2- Earthquake MKIV-15
3- Velodyne HGS-18
Before these I owned a Polk PSW 650. First, the SVS package. After finding the best position (both corner-loaded up front) & calibrating via test tones and spl meter, I was initially some-what dissatisfied. After growing accustomed to "TRUE, CLEAN BASS", I quickly fell in love with them. I felt like a little kid after recieving that bicycle for x-mas. These subs are so quick and accurate. Only I didn't "TRULY KNOW" to what extent until later on. However, I did find their limits quickly. Since they play so low & clean, you can bottom them out easily (if you are a bass-head like myself). Oh, by-the-way. My HT area is huge with 18ft ceilings & a loft.
Mr. Earthquake was next. I was immediately impressed with it's small size and rugged finish (A+ rating). This sub is entirely different from the SVS subs. It has the most powerful amp I have ever experienced in a HT sub...PERIOD!!! Lights would dim and I could only stand the volume on the sub at 3, maybe 4 tops (out of 10)!!! Highly under-rated amp (it MUST-BE high-current or something)! This sub goes very low, but when you reach 25HZ and below, the svs subs & Velodyne are MUCH cleaner & play lower, faster! The earthquake just seems to "rumble a lot compared to the other two below 25HZ. The earthquake sounded best behind the seating position for some reason. This sub has a single 15" driver & a 15" passive radiator. These combined produce the most VIOLENT BASS I've ever heard or felt...PERIOD!!! Leaves the SVS & Velodyne in the dust above 25HZ! Forget the "bass-shakers,etc". This sub is simply put,"the devil, himself" when it comes to moving you!
Now the Velodyne is an interesting sub. It is huge, and beautiful. The built-in amp is rated at 1250 rms/3000 max! Uhhhhh...yeah, ok. Don't get me wrong, it is a powerful amp but the earthquake amp is in a league of its own! The HGS-18 did prove to cover the ground in-between both the svs & earthquake subs. It played VERY, VERY LOW! It was VERY quick! Amazing, considering it is an 18" driver! It put out the "biggest bass" I've heard in a HT sub. That term I used is sort of hard to explain. The bass just seemed like it covered more area, especially when position behind the seating area. It was almost as quick as the svs subs & much, much faster than the earthquake. It sounded like someone had a "huge air-cannon" up front and felt "like a giant just sat on you" when positioned behind the seating area. However, I had the gain on this sub maxed out.
Final analysis: For super clean, super quick, & natural low bass, but not as much Body-moving bass as the other two, go with SVS 20-39CS+ subs.
For "No Holds Barred", "Simply VIOLENT" 25HZ + bass, the earthquake is KING-KONG here! Don't get me wrong, this sub will play way below 20HZ. The sound just isn't as gratifying as the other two.
For the best of both worlds, choose Velodyne HGS-18. It plays low, almost as clean as the svs subs, but gives you more shake. I must also add that it sounds GREAT up front & just as good in back. Very versitile. The SVS subs had little impact behind the seating position in my HT area!
I am probably going to keep the Velodyne HGS-18!
I hope this has helped everyone still uncertain about which sub to choose. These are 3 of the best subs $ can buy. All three are superb, but each is very different. It all depends on what "YOU" want!
Thank you
Rob