johnSM
Second Unit
- Joined
- May 24, 2006
- Messages
- 439
- Real Name
- John
It is incorrect because it sounds wrong, many noticed the mistake - enough for Lucasfilm to have to comment on it - and also because it has now been fixed for the impending bluray release... Regardless of the process used to create the surround channels for the 2004 DVD, the channels could have been 'reflipped' in just about ANY audio editing program to sound correct once again! This is Star Wars we're talking about, and many lesser films from the same era have been done correctly without all these problems...Douglas Monce said:How would they be "correct" or "incorrect", when the films never had split surrounds before the special edition release? Even the 70mm 6 track used mono surrounds as that was the format before Apocalypse Now introduced the 5.1 format we know today. Doug