I agree that Paul Mavis not noticing the music change was very strange for someone familiar with the show. No way to get around that one. It's indefensible in terms of calling yourself a "fanatic" of the show. I just think, in reading the other site's forum at the time, that Paul took too much heat. He was receiving hate mail, nasty emails, even threats against his family over this. And I think we can all agree that that was way over the top. In fact a forum regular here, Bob Hug, went to that other site and after quoting Mr. Mavis saying how he had been getting threatening and harassing emails over the this issue, wrote the following statement which I think bears repeating here. Bob Hug said:
That kinda sums up my feelings on the matter and I'll leave it at that. Heck, we are talking about something that happened several years ago and I'd like to think sane people can let that type of stuff go after years pass. I know that's how I try to live my life.
Gary "no offense toward anyone - I think everyone here is a good 'Joe' and I always appreciate different perspectives" O.
That's just wrong on so many levels and, with respect to threatening e-mails, may even be illegal. It's really disheartening to hear that one man's appraisal of this DVD release could result in so much venom being directed at him. If you honestly disagree with what he has to say, you can do so in a forum like this, but please, folks, keep it civil.
Mr. Mavis is a reviewer whom I've come to greatly appreciate over the last several years, especially as it pertains to vintage TV-on-DVD releases; in that regard, I've found him to be among the very best writers covering this area in a thoughtful and in-depth manner that few other reviewers can match, not only for the great number of reviews that he has written but, more importantly, for the quality of his reviews (if you want to read a truly great in-depth review, I suggest that you read his assessment of Shout! Factory's release of "The Adventures of Ozzie & Harriet" last year . . . . hands down the best review of a vintage TV show I've ever had the pleasure to read). For those that say "he should of known about the music changes," all I can say is "no one's perfect." Would another reviewer here at DVD Talk have noticed them? Perhaps. But if you do read the few reviews of this DVD release on the web, it appears that other reviewers have missed it as well. As Mr. Mavis has stated in his above post "If you don't like the opinion, don't read my stuff. It truly is that simple." I'd actually take that one step further, if you don't like what CBS Paramount has done with this DVD release, don't buy it!
That kinda sums up my feelings on the matter and I'll leave it at that. Heck, we are talking about something that happened several years ago and I'd like to think sane people can let that type of stuff go after years pass. I know that's how I try to live my life.
Gary "no offense toward anyone - I think everyone here is a good 'Joe' and I always appreciate different perspectives" O.